Okay here's the contest on my Batman's >>> Prize is Pictured in Post

[Smittys]

Guess the Grade of the 25 Batman issues pictured below.

All are on their way to CGS for grading

Winner will Receive a Detective Comics number 186 also pictured below.

The person with the most right guess will win the detective comic.

In the case of a tie, winner will be drawn random from the tiers.

Only grade the 25 issues of Batman.

One entry per person.

 

Most of the batman have better scans which have been shown on here.

I just don't know how to search for them, if you do it'll help with your guessing.

 

Let the guessing begin.

Post your guesses here.

Good luck got about 25ish days before results will be in.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[tortoise]

Can't guess any grades w/o back covers.

[Smittys]

Click on my name look at my post and you'll see the books with back covers in separate posting

[Sandflea]

Can't guess any grades w/o back covers.

 

Agreed...plus, the Batman #42 pic has the front lower-left corner cropped off, and the books are bagged & boarded. Straight scans of books un-bagged would be better for guessible accuracy...

[Smittys]

Can't guess any grades w/o back covers.

 

Agreed...plus, the Batman #42 pic has the front lower-left corner cropped off, and the books are bagged & boarded. Straight scans of books un-bagged would be better for guessible accuracy...

 

Click on my name look at my post and you'll see the books with back covers in separate posting

[Sandflea]

Can't guess any grades w/o back covers.

 

Agreed...plus, the Batman #42 pic has the front lower-left corner cropped off, and the books are bagged & boarded. Straight scans of books un-bagged would be better for guessible accuracy...

 

Click on my name look at my post and you'll see the books with back covers in separate posting

 

(thumbs u

[Spiderphill]

#40 - 4.0

#42 - 4.0

#46 - 4.5

#47 - 5.0

#48 - 5.5

#49 - 6.5

#51 - 6.0

#54 - 6.5

#55 - 4.0

#56 - 5.0

#57 - 3.0

#58 - 5.0

#59 - 4.5

#60 - 7.5

#61 - 5.5

#62 - 8.0

#63 - 5.5

#64 - 7.5

#66 - 7.5

#67 - 6.5

#68 - 7.0

#69 - 4.0

#71 - 8.0

#72 - 4.5

#73 - 6.0

 

tec 137 3.0

tec 164 8.5

tec 165 6.5

tec 169 7.0

tec 185 4.0

 

 

Thanks for the chance at the prize, also a very nice run you purchased. If scans of the BC come up, hope I can adjust my grades. These are based off FC.

 

 

 

[asr0462]

I just enjoyed looking at the covers.

[Sandflea]

My "guesstimations"...

 

 

1. Batman #40-----3.0

 

2. Batman #42-----2.5

 

3. Batman #46-----5.0

 

4. Batman #47-----4.0

 

5. Batman #48-----5.5

 

6. Batman #49-----5.5

 

7. Batman #51-----6.0

 

8. Batman #54-----5.5

 

9. Batman #55-----5.0

 

10. Batman #56-----4.5

 

11. Batman #57-----1.8

 

12. Batman #58-----5.0

 

13. Batman #59-----4.5

 

14. Batman #60-----7.0

 

15. Batman #61-----7.0

 

16. Batman #62-----6.5

 

17. Batman #63-----7.0

 

18. Batman #64-----6.0

 

19. Batman #66-----6.5

 

20. Batman# 67-----7.0

 

21. Batman #68-----6.0

 

22. Batman #69-----3.5

 

23. Batman #71-----6.0

 

24. Batman #72-----4.5

 

25. Batman #73-----4.5

 

 

[mrchocholat]

My kick at the can

 

 

1. Batman #40-----3.5

 

2. Batman #42-----3.0

 

3. Batman #46-----4.0

 

4. Batman #47-----4.0

 

5. Batman #48-----5.0

 

6. Batman #49-----7.0

 

7. Batman #51-----5.0

 

8. Batman #54-----5.0(possible trim)

 

9. Batman #55-----3.5

 

10. Batman #56-----4.5

 

11. Batman #57-----2.5

 

12. Batman #58-----3.0

 

13. Batman #59-----3.5

 

14. Batman #60-----6.5

 

15. Batman #61-----5.0

 

16. Batman #62-----6.0

 

17. Batman #63-----4.5

 

18. Batman #64-----8.0

 

19. Batman #66-----7.0

 

20. Batman# 67-----5.5

 

21. Batman #68-----5.0

 

22. Batman #69-----3.5

 

23. Batman #71-----8.5

 

24. Batman #72-----3.0

 

25. Batman #73-----4.5

 

26. tec #137-----3.0

 

26. tec #164-----5.5

 

26. tec #165-----4.5

 

26. tec #169-----7.0

 

26. tec #185-----2.5

 

26. tec #186-----3.0

[MR SigS]

B&R

#40=3.0

#42=3.0

#46=4.5

#47=5.0

#48=5.5

#49=7.0

#51=7.0

#54=7.5

#55=4.0

#56=4.0

#57=2.5

#58=6.5

#59=5.0

#60=8.0

#61=6.5

#62=6.0

#63=7.5

#64=6.5

#66=7.5

#67=5.5

#68=5.0

#69=3.0

#71=7.5

#72=4.0

#73=7.0

 

Great Contest! Great Practice! Great Answers! Right? Right?

This is very generous of you. Thanks

Super collection

[Spiderphill]

Looks like Im very generous on the grades . First contest though and I'm far from a solid grader.

[MR SigS]

Why do you say that?

[Spiderphill]

My grades are higher than everyone else by a decent margin

[MR SigS]

Oh.

Heck, you could be spot on.

 

 

Though I hope you're not

 

 

[Green]

4.5 on all of them.

[MR SigS]

[Conan_Aficionado]

when does this contest end?

 

never mind, another classic reading comprehension fail.

 

25ish days or so, got it.

[Conan_Aficionado]

4.5 on all of them.

 

what's funny, is that it will probably average out and you'll win this contest.

[RockMyAmadeus]

I hate you for your beautiful Bats.

 

But I'll take a crack at grades.