Swamp Thing #1

[telerites]

Off to Joey for a press and sub - it has a production crease that you see on the back cover. I'm hoping that top corner crunch can be pressed out.

 

What do you think it may grade at?

 

 

 

 

[Cimm]

Given that the top corner crease presses out... 9.4 (there's a small amount of color break going on at the extreme bottom left front cover, it appears, preventing 9.6 or higher, IMO)

[NuffSaid57]

Nice book. What is the mark in the corner ding on BC? Depending whether the corner ding can be pressed out and cleaned up 9.2/9.4

[telerites]

Nice book. What is the mark in the corner ding on BC? Depending whether the corner ding can be pressed out and cleaned up 9.2/9.4

 

Some type of ink transfer or overspray would be my guess. I see no CT on the covers.

 

My hope when Joey does his caressing magic would a 9.4. I agree with Cimm that it would be tough to pull higher.

[oakman29]

9.2 (thumbs u

[faster friends]

9.2+

[etanick]

the slight color loss in the purple area will still be there I think but a 9.4 is still possible.

[Junkdrawer]

could come back 9.0 from CGC hope for a 9.2

[Sandflea]

9.2 (thumbs u

 

+1

[ARK]

9.2 (thumbs u

 

+1

 

+2

[Topnotchman]

The upper front corner has creasing in the purple, the lower front outside corner and edge has some creasing. The lower front spine corner has a ding also. Looking in line with a 9.0.

[Wrightson fan]

9.2

[divad]

could come back 9.0 from CGC hope for a 9.2

 

That's what I'm thinking . . .

[joeypost]

9.0

[divad]

The upper front corner has creasing in the purple, the lower front outside corner and edge has some creasing. The lower front spine corner has a ding also. Looking in line with a 9.0.

 

As articulated above

[Dr_Neff]

9.2 (thumbs u

 

+1

 

+2

 

+4 (thumbs u

[Thermal]

9.0 Sorry

 

[telerites]

9.0 Sorry

 

 

Don't apologize. I appreciate yours and the other thoughts. Who knows what it will grade CGC will give it. I remember when I posted my TMNT #1 - I had grades that ranged from 9.0 to 9.4 and it came back as a 9.8. Other times, folks thought books would grade higher when they came back lower.

 

I just appreciate the honest comments. (thumbs u

[Catwoman-migration]

Over all it's a great looking book 9.0.

[MR SigS]

[font:Comic Sans MS]Even with a press I don't think the two bottom corners will yield better than 9.2 tops IMHO[/font]