PGM B&B #28

[higgsboson]

would love to get opinions. Looks much better than my CGC 4.0, but really wonder what that upper right corner will do.

 

By higgsboson70 at 2011-12-16

 

By higgsboson70 at 2011-12-16

 

By higgsboson70 at 2011-12-16

 

[oakman29]

3.5 (thumbs u

[etanick]

i will go with 4.0

[Mio]

4

[BlowUpTheMoon]

4.0 just because of the top right FC corner.

[Wilson3d]

4.0 just because of the top right FC corner.

 

+1

[faster friends]

4.0-

[Aces]

4.0 small shot at 4.5 but nothing higher.

[excelsior1986]

4.5 sounds good to me. nice looking book.

 

you'll pop that centerfold laying it on a flat surface like that, silver DCs are notorious for popping their centerfolds and ive done it myself before.

[divad]

4.0 small shot at 4.5 but nothing higher.

 

+1

[davidhartnyc-migration]

I'd say 4.0 or 4.5

[DR.X]

Solid 4.0 for me, but with that corner I just can't go 4.5 unless its an on-site submission. Then 6.0.

 

DR.X

[NuffSaid57]

On second look can't really disagree with the 4.0's, but my first impression was 3.5

[ARK]

I'm with the rest of the 4.0 crowd.

[evi1pau1]

 

Solid 4.0 for me, but with that corner I just can't go 4.5 unless its an on-site submission. Then 6.0.

 

DR.X

 

What does an onsite submission mean?? I'm guessing this is a joke?...why would a grade increase so much? (from 4.0 to 6.0)

[Dr_Neff]

3.5 love that book. I've had nice fingerprint copies, and even someone drew a penguin on one

[higgsboson]

4.5 sounds good to me. nice looking book.

 

you'll pop that centerfold laying it on a flat surface like that, silver DCs are notorious for popping their centerfolds and ive done it myself before.

 

Luckily no damage, but you're right they just don't like to lay open unsupported. Thanks for all the quick feedback. Based on the general concesus here I decided to return it, as it was well overgraded by the comic connect "verified" grade. No hassles about returning it. They may not know how to grade, but they have always been helpful when I've talked to them about anything. Hmm, so what should I buy instead? Fun fun fun. Eventually Ill find a decent priced upgrade for my 4.0.