Grading request

[Floob]

Hi,

 

Could someone please give their grading estimates on these please.

I'm wondering if my scans are big enough,

 

The Brave & the Bold #36

Front

Back

 

The Brave & the Bold #44

Front

Back

 

Jonah Hex #1

Front

Back

[Zanarkand]

B&B 36, G+ 2.5 tops. Tape stains and the piece off the back, loose cover.

 

B&B 44, possible VG/F 5.0.

 

Joneh Hex 1, probably VF 8.0.

[NewtSamson]

B&B 36, G+ 2.5 tops. Tape stains and the piece off the back, loose cover.

 

B&B 44, possible VG/F 5.0.

 

Joneh Hex 1, probably VF 8.0.

yea I think your first two grades are probably what I'd give it, but I'm gonna have to give Jonag Hex a 8.5....it looks pretty solid.

[Fan4Fan]

B&B 36: 2.0 tops

 

B&B 44: 4.0-4.5.

 

Joneh Hex 1: probably VF 8.0.

[Floob]

Thanks very much for your responses.

It really helps get a good idea of how to grade.

 

So based on that, would you say this is a 2 max?

 

X-Men #1

Front

[Fan4Fan]

I'd say less, given the spine damage (among other things).

 

Thanks,

Fan4Fan

[uclapeterg]

B&B 36: 2.0

B&B 44: 3.5

JH 1: 8.0

[uclapeterg]

Xmen 1: 1.5

[Aces]

The Brave & the Bold #36

H2O damage! 1.8

 

The Brave & the Bold #44

Not too bad... 4.0/4.5

 

Jonah Hex #1

Nice! 8.0/8.5

 

And the X-men 1............. 1.0

[sterlingcomics]

B&B 36, G+ 2.5 tops. Tape stains and the piece off the back, loose cover.

 

B&B 44, possible VG/F 5.0.

 

Joneh Hex 1, probably VF 8.0.

 

above grades are accurate estimates IMHO.

 

X-Men #1 is between 1.0 and 1.5

 

Oh, and...

WELCOME TO THE BOARDS

[Zanarkand]

Thanks very much for your responses.

It really helps get a good idea of how to grade.

 

So based on that, would you say this is a 2 max?

 

X-Men #1

Front

 

Heavy cover wear, heavy creasing, multiple tears, discoloration... What's with the spine? Is that a long split, tape, or what? Splits longer than a couple of inches put a book in Fair country.

[Stronguy]

The Brave & the Bold #36

GD -- hate those tape stains

The Brave & the Bold #44

VG

Jonah Hex #1

VF

[Stronguy]

Thanks very much for your responses.

It really helps get a good idea of how to grade.

 

So based on that, would you say this is a 2 max?

 

X-Men #1

Front

 

Yikes!!!

 

I'll say GD just from what I can see.

 

BTW, I think I have you beat on POS X-Men #1...

 

[Calamerica]

B&B 36, G+ 2.5 tops. Tape stains and the piece off the back, loose cover.

 

B&B 44, possible VG/F 5.0.

 

Joneh Hex 1, probably VF 8.0.

 

Pretty close!

 

CAL