Favorite What if..?

[s-man]

My pick is "What if Pheonix had not died?"

 

Being a big fan of the Pheonix Saga it was interesting to see just how bad it wouldve been had she (it) not died on the moon!

[ArAich]

"What if I had actually read What If ?"....

[drdonaldblake]

i really enjoyed the story, what if conan lived in the 20th century, i cant remember the exact number of the book but it was from the 1st series and had an awesome painted cover

 

it was a cool story- about conan living like a barbarian but in todays times

[zooklandrox-migration]

What if.......Wolverine had killed the Hulk?

[deathlok]

i really enjoyed the story, what if conan lived in the 20th century, i cant remember the exact number of the book but it was from the 1st series and had an awesome painted cover

 

it was a cool story- about conan living like a barbarian but in todays times

[delekkerste]

i really enjoyed the story, what if conan lived in the 20th century, i cant remember the exact number of the book but it was from the 1st series and had an awesome painted cover

 

it was a cool story- about conan living like a barbarian but in todays times

 

That was a good one. I liked the scene where Conan beats up some guy and takes his coins, but throws away the "worthless" paper money.

[the_Greatest]

What if Spider-Man aged in Real Time? He'd be....58 ?

 

"c'mere you little bassturd. don't make me shoot my web at you"

[s-man]

i really enjoyed the story, what if conan lived in the 20th century, i cant remember the exact number of the book but it was from the 1st series and had an awesome painted cover

 

it was a cool story- about conan living like a barbarian but in todays times

 

more like "What if Conan were Dirty Harry!!"

[shadroch]

Wasn't there an earlier What if? where Conan fights

Captain America and the story hints at him joining the Avengers? Don't think this is that story.

[goldust40]

Have to say I thought that What If #1 (What If Spider-Man had joined the Fantastic Four) was very enjoyable, with nice characterization and a decent plot/-script.

 

I admit I like issue 30's story (What If Peter Parker's clone had lived).

[the_Greatest]

[deathlok]

Wasn't there an earlier What if? where Conan fights

Captain America and the story hints at him joining the Avengers? Don't think this is that story.

[drdonaldblake]

yeah, thats the issue!!

 

thanx deathlok for posting it- i read that when i was 13 or 14 y.o or thereabouts

 

sure brings back some fond memeories!

[shadroch]

Yep,thats the one. When I read the books off the newstands,this was one of the few I really enjoyed.

I liked #1,and a few of the others but this was the last Marvel title I would read every month,even after a few DCs,believe it or not.Got a real kick out of the issue that had Stan and Jack and the bullpen become the Fantastic Four,for about two pages.Most of these books were best left to the imagination.

[s-man]

Yep,thats the one. When I read the books off the newstands,this was one of the few I really enjoyed.

I liked #1,and a few of the others but this was the last Marvel title I would read every month,even after a few DCs,believe it or not.Got a real kick out of the issue that had Stan and Jack and the bullpen become the Fantastic Four,for about two pages.Most of these books were best left to the imagination.

 

One of the things I liked about the series was the Watcher playing host... he played the part of Hitchcock or Rod Sterling well!

[Brother J]

Here's my favorite What If? issue:

 

[s-man]

WELCOME TO THE BOARDS!

[deathlok]

Was this on anyone's list?

 

[Mephisto]

What If Spider-Man's Clone Had Lived?...Oh wait it did, but then it died again, so I guess if a new What If series comes along they could make another What If Spider-Man's Clone Had Lived?

[deathlok]

wow what a surprise, the Hulk goes berzerk. Like doesn't that happen in almost every issue of the hulk. It's not the words "HULK SMASH" is a calming mantra.