Golden Age Grading Fun!

[FlyingDonut]

Your grading thoughts on these:

 

Uncle Scrooge 16:

 

 

Superman 53:

 

 

Debating whether or not to get them slabbed.

[murph0]

The Scrooge, I'd say F- mostly b/c it's G.A.?

Superman I'd say in the realm of G- at best mostly due to the piece missing.

 

Brian

[tb]

VG/FN & G

[aardvark88]

U.S. fn-, Superman gd but depends on how big chunk is on back cvr too.

[Bonds25]

FN+ on the Uncle Scrooge, and G+ on the Superman.

[awe4one]

I agrew with Bonds - FN+ on US and GD for Supes.

 

 

Jim

[lighthouse]

6.5 on the Scrooge...

 

2.5 on the Supes (although I have seen 3.0's with pieces missing this size...

[Guest]

VG/F on the Scrooge and G- on the Superman

[Bronty]

I'm with bonds too. 6.5 and 2.5.

[hammer-migration]

6.0 / 2.0 Not worth slabbing.

[Darthdiesel]

Not one to let a thread die: More golden age grading fun?

 

[Bugaboo-migration]

I didn't even know Fantastic Four #51 was a Golden Age book.......silly me.

[awe4one]

I'd say 9.2 but I want to give it a 9.4. A bit too many spine creases though. Regardless, that's a damn fine copy Darth.

 

 

Jim

[Darthdiesel]

Sorry - Silver better? Umm..We're using Ebay Golden Age???

[Darthdiesel]

Thanks! Yes...darn those creases...time to iron those suckers out!!!

[fantastic_four]

That's the reprint from the 1990s of Fantastic Four 51, isn't it?

[chromium]

The colours reminded me of the Marvel Masterworks version.....

[murph0]

Hard to see the corners, VF/NM

 

Brian

[Bonds25]

Looks a little too perfect to me, but if this is the actual scan, probably a 9.2.

[Darthdiesel]

FF - great call - you are on the money! No what gave it away? My retailer was about to charge me $40 for it and I told him to take it out, lo and behold there is an X-Men video game ad on the back...! It is nice, but by modern standards, it'd probably CGC at 8.5