Xmen 11 & 12

[gadzukes]

Thanks in advance.

 

Would these touch 8.0?

 

 

 

[HotJuicyBurgers]

Is that water damage top right hand corner of the back cover of number 11?

[gadzukes]

Yes, it has a hint of a stain in the upper right just on the back

[HotJuicyBurgers]

I'd say 11 7.0/7.5

 

12 6.0/6.5

 

But what do I know?

[Lost]

The more I get CGC's back the more I'm convinced they go with "feel" not measuring defects....Both feel like 8.0 to me with the nice white backs and gloss and very minor edge defects that I see some in the 9.0 range in silvers.

 

I think if you did some erasing magic on the back of the 11 near the staples and got it pressed I could see 7.0. to 7.5 (8 if no waterstain?)

 

I think the 12 doesn't need much except straighting the bends out of the front cover if safe and possible and probably see 8.0...not sure what is wrong with it to deserve a 6.0 :-P

[Phill the Governor]

7.0/7.5 and 8.0

[Hado]

The whites on 12 seem too bright is that from your camera?

[gadzukes]

The whites on 12 seem too bright is that from your camera?

 

I take my pics without the flash on because I always get glare with the flash. The whites are very white on 12 but the camera did make it look even whiter.

[HotJuicyBurgers]

The more I get CGC's back the more I'm convinced they go with "feel" not measuring defects....Both feel like 8.0 to me with the nice white backs and gloss and very minor edge defects that I see some in the 9.0 range in silvers.

 

I think if you did some erasing magic on the back of the 11 near the staples and got it pressed I could see 7.0. to 7.5 (8 if no waterstain?)

 

I think the 12 doesn't need much except straighting the bends out of the front cover if safe and possible and probably see 8.0...not sure what is wrong with it to deserve a 6.0 :-P

 

I'm new to this, so I though maybe all that overhang was something that knocked the comic hard?

 

How is something like that graded?

[Lost]

Coulda been manufacturing defect.... or the way it was stored. lots of older books have printing defects that are either ignored or very relaxed. I think if the overhang had all rips and chew marks it would be downgraded...but thats just a little wrinkled in...

[roulette44]

they look pretty nice, but 8.0 on both might be a stretch....are you looking at the slabbing costs and basically coming to the conclusion it's not worth the slab costs unless it gets 8.0+?

[mar-vell]

7.5

8.0