PGM - Fantastic Four #5 - Grade is IN

[Primetime]

5.0/5.5, but CGC will say 6.0/6.5

[Spider-Dan]

Just got the grade from CGC

 

7.5 OW/W

 

I wonder what it would have gotten with a press

 

Thanks for all who chimed in

[vaillant]

That’s wonderful Spider-Dan, but now you have entombed it!

 

Marvel chipping is a production defect, so that’s why they aren’t tough on it.

I prefer Marvel chipping to miswraps, that book is a gorgeous copy!

[etanick]

7.5

 

nice...I thought 7.0 would have been possible but a long shot.

 

Heck, time to crack/press/resub my ASM 7.0 to an 7.5 or higher then

 

oh, and this should also answer any questions on how big marker writing on the interior can hurt the grade...not.

[Spiderphill]

Thanks everyone for your opinion.

 

I was thinking 6.5/7.0 - I think Ill send it in to CGC before I try and sell it (thumbs u

Should be a lock. Instantly thought 6.5/7 when I saw the scans/pictures. CGC it for sure.

i was on the higher end of the group. Nice score.

[vaillant]

It’s just a beautiful book.

Kid Holmes signature play is probably more annoying than the Marvel chipping, but so nice, I would have never CGC'd it. I have to read it!

[Comicdey]

Holy carp. 7.5. I just got a sweet pre hero Tos back with marvel chipping at 6.5 ..... Hmmmmmm

[thehumantorch]

Congrats, that's a big win of a grade.