Grading help please: Daredevil #23

[divad]

Love this cover!:

 

 

 

 

thank you!

[Aces]

Reading creases that run the length of the cover really hurt the structural grade.

 

F-(5.5) but the eye-appeal of a FVF

[Stout1]

A nice book. A little less stress and it would of been a solid 5.5. But as it is, a nice 5.0

[jimm94]

How bad is the spine roll when it's not being pressed flat by the scanner lid?

 

I'd say 4.5, or perhaps 5.0 if it's a light roll.

[uclapeterg]

4.5.

[143ksk]

4.5.

 

[Susanville]

Hawaii 5.0

[FFB]

Put me down for 5.5.

[divad]

How bad is the spine roll when it's not being pressed flat by the scanner lid?

 

I'd say 4.5, or perhaps 5.0 if it's a light roll.

 

No spine roll at all, although I see your point in the scan . . . especially with the offset of the pages on the back cover. Must have been on the bottom of a stack.

 

Thanks guys, I thought perhaps, I could've squeaked it by at a FN 6.0 - the gloss is great.

 

-divad

[nik]

VG/FN

[uclapeterg]

Put me down for 5.5.

 

Lenient [!@#%^&^]!!

[osborn_fr]

6.0

[burntboy]

yup - i think the 5.0-6.0 votes have got it right. and YES, it is a VERY cool cover

[FFB]

Put me down for 5.5.

 

Lenient [!@#%^&^]!!

 

Harry agrees with me, which automatically means that he thinks you're stupid.

[uclapeterg]

Put me down for 5.5.

 

Lenient [!@#%^&^]!!

 

Harry agrees with me, which automatically means that he thinks you're stupid.

 

Harry? Who's Harry?

[FFB]

Put me down for 5.5.

 

Lenient [!@#%^&^]!!

 

Harry agrees with me, which automatically means that he thinks you're stupid.

 

Harry? Who's Harry?

 

Burntboy.

[uclapeterg]

Put me down for 5.5.

 

Lenient [!@#%^&^]!!

 

Harry agrees with me, which automatically means that he thinks you're stupid.

 

Harry? Who's Harry?

 

Burntboy.

 

BB don't know [!@#%^&^]!