PGM Weird Science 13

[AJD]

I think I know what the answer is - just want a few other opinions please.

 

This books sits flat, has only slight darkening of the interior cover and the pages are OW/W. Thanks in advance!

 

 

[rjpb]

4.0/4.5

[oakman29]

4.0 I love EC books.

[Hado]

Agree 4.0/4.5

[dcmannn]

+1

[DR.X]

4.0

 

If the centerfold and cover are attached. Nice book.

[Phill the Governor]

Solid 5.0

[Point Five]

I agree with 5.0. Positive qualities despite the wear.

 

(I hate to ask, but any chance there's a hit or two of color touch on that longish corner crease? I hope it's just my screen, but seems like the color break kind of blips in and out a bit.)

 

 

[FineCollector]

4.0

[pmpknface]

I was thinking 4.0 on average too.

[AJD]

Thanks guys. In hand I thought the book was 5.0 but could see 4.5 on a harsh day.

 

In any case, your views reinforce my decision to send it back to the seller as being well below 6.0.

 

Point Five: no, I don't think so. The crease is a very fine one but under a magnifying lamp all looks ok.

[Point Five]

(thumbs u

 

 

[ARK]

I'm with a 4.5.

Great book Andrew!

[rjpb]

Thanks guys. In hand I thought the book was 5.0 but could see 4.5 on a harsh day.

 

In any case, your views reinforce my decision to send it back to the seller as being well below 6.0.

 

Point Five: no, I don't think so. The crease is a very fine one but under a magnifying lamp all looks ok.

 

Definitely outside the range of acceptability for a 6.0, unless the price was cheap enough and you could live with a VGish copy. I know it's a pain, but sending stuff like this back is the only way to send the message that a seller's grading is unacceptable. I wish I'd done more of it back in the 90s, when one was frequently buying blind.

[dr_manhattan]

4.5

[dcmannn]

4.5/5.0

[Aces]

4.5/5.0

[Foxtrot70]

I was thinking 5.0 , but no lower than 4.5 on bad day. Cover tanning is common on ECs. Nice PQ. If you paid less than $85 keep it. The book is a nice filler until you can complete your run and replace w higher mid-grade.

[vaillant]

It looks in the VG range, surely not in the FN range (which starts at 5.5), so if you are not attached at the book, I’d ask for return. Otherwise, just ask some discount.

[divad]

Solid 5.0

 

Agreed