Re: PGM Spellbound #1 - (1951) grade in.

[Lost]

Obvious issue is the lower right FC. small stains on the back. They aren't chips. Thanks!

 

 

 

[Phill the Governor]

7.5. How are the staples/centerfold?

[Lost]

tight

[rjpb]

Very nice copy. Don't know that I'd go 7.5, even though the flaws are pretty small.

 

7.0

[BarryAllen]

6.5

[DR.X]

6.5 for me also. That chip off that lower corner is going to keep it from going higher IMO. That back cover may clean up a bit also.

 

Really a great looking book with great color and eye appeal.

[crazyhips]

5.5

[Lost]

Ill post it round 9pm tonight for those who wanna test their grading skills against cgc...

[divad]

Very nice copy. Don't know that I'd go 7.5, even though the flaws are pretty small.

 

7.0

 

What he said

[timfinz]

6.0 IMHO. I think it presents better but the combination of defects tells me different. good luck with the grade (thumbs u

[Boboset]

7.0 camp

[Mailman_Comics]

6.0

[Lost]

This got a cgc 7.0.

 

I can see why people graded it lower but you kinda have to pull yourself 4 to 5 ft from the screen when you give the grade... else even 9.2's look bad.

 

Bright inks, great reflectivity, tight and flat. I was expecting 6.5 so a rare pleasant surprise based on my luck lately.

[timfinz]

Good stuff! It's a great looking book! Congratulations on the grade! (thumbs u

[divad]

Very nice copy. Don't know that I'd go 7.5, even though the flaws are pretty small.

 

7.0

 

What he said

 

 

[whetteon]

I'm saying 6.0. Nice book. (thumbs u

[rjpb]

Very nice copy. Don't know that I'd go 7.5, even though the flaws are pretty small.

 

7.0

 

What he said

 

 

 

Because I can grade from a scan.

[divad]

Very nice copy. Don't know that I'd go 7.5, even though the flaws are pretty small.

 

7.0

 

What he said

 

 

 

Because I can grade from a scan.

 

 

[Boboset]

7.0 camp

Since I was left out of all the back padding going on here. Suck it.

[timfinz]

7.0 camp

Since I was left out of all the back padding going on here. Suck it.

Sorry man! Ta dah! way to go Boboset!