Spare me a grade? X-Men 11

[PT]

Just wondering if you could help me with some comics I would like a grade on, I am trying to get it sorted in my head, not done much grading before, and would like your opinions to confirm/throw out my own.

 

I have uploaded the images to my flickr accout, you should be able to see them here:

And this is just 3 for the day, I won't bombard the boards!

 

X-Men 11 - Lays nice and flat, the pages are tanning inside, you can see some of the inside cover through the front page in Xaviers head and the yellow X - thin pages?

 

Front -

 

Back -

 

 

Like I said I would really appreciate some grading advice here (not selling, just practice) and why ou think it would achieve the specific grade.

 

Cheers folks,

 

P.

[vaillant]

Hi PTaylor – I think it can be more handy to have each one in a separate thread: with three you are just fine and evaluations will be more focused. (thumbs u

[vaillant]

Ah, and welcome to the Boards!

[PT]

Cool, will split them up now, sorry about that

[timfinz]

The scans are small but here's a guess anyway,

X-men #11 5.0 to 5.5

Avengers #16 4.5 to 5.0

Avengers #6 4.0 to 4.5

IMHO

 

 

[vaillant]

A little help for those unfamiliar with Flickr:

 

I love this book… and still miss one!

 

 

[PT]

A little help for those unfamiliar with Flickr:

 

I love this book… and still miss one!

 

Me too, one of my earliest, love the story and that artwork.

[SkinnerSweet]

I'd say a 5.5

[Wilson3d]

I'm in the 5.5 group but also think it could possibly be a 6.0

[FunnyBooks1969]

5,5 is about right me thinks, maybe a press could help