GUESS THE GRADE - DAREDEVIL 131 1ST BULLSEYE - RESUBMITTED

[jsilverjanet]

picked this up from a board member who had cracked the slab. curious to see where the group scores this vs CGC - will reveal the label tomorrow night (no cheating)

 

 

 

 

SCORE - CGC LABEL

 

 

 

 

 

BOOK WAS PRESSED AND RESUBMITTED 5/2014

 

 

 

 

[Lost]

guessing like 6.5/7.0 if it was recently graded.

[jsilverjanet]

it was graded sometime ago. Book was cracked and stored and purchased in the same condition (as it was in the slab)

 

 

[ROBTOTHEC]

7.5

[The-Collector]

is that foxing on the top right corner FC? It looks strange to me. not quite foxing but no quite ink.

[jsilverjanet]

I'm not sure what it is

[jaybes]

Considering I've been about a point low on these guess the grades lately, I'm saying 7.0.

 

Love that book, btw.

[The-Collector]

Hmm i am not sure then. The book looks structurally pretty nice. i will say 7.5/8.0 assuming those are stains or foxing and not ink. If dist or production ink i would say 9.0.

[Mystafo]

8.0 over here

[ARK]

8.0 here.

[vaillant]

Considered it would be a pretty awesome copy, apart from that possible staining (or the like), I’d say 8.0.

[timfinz]

I'm thinking 7.5

[vaillant]

I'm thinking 7.5

 

Such minor staining should not bring the grade down more than a single point, and this is better than a 8.5 without the staining, IMO.

[timfinz]

I'm thinking 7.5

 

Such minor staining should not bring the grade down more than a single point, and this is better than a 8.5 without the staining, IMO.

It's not the staining so much. There is impact damage at both the top and bottom of the back cover. TLHS and BRHS. Additionally there is a color scratch on DD's right ankle and there is more dirt or some sort of deposit on the front cover. Above the right shoulder and to the left of DD's left foot in the Marvel box LHS, above the first 'D', in the 'A', the second 'E', the second 'D' and the 'V' and a similar dirt spec on DD's right arm and chest area. There is another ink spot next to the word "misses!" in the caption. There a numerous spine stresses as well IMHO.

[jsilverjanet]

 

I will say the book looks great in hand but it does have some serious flaws IMHO

 

can't wait

[southerncross]

I'm at 7.5

[timfinz]

 

I will say the book looks great in hand but it does have some serious flaws IMHO

 

can't wait

I'm hoping the CGC graders are more lenient then I am when guessing a grade for these books. I believe you when you say it looks great in hand! (thumbs u

[thunsicker]

I'd guess 8.0.

[jsilverjanet]

Hmm i am not sure then. The book looks structurally pretty nice. i will say 7.5/8.0 assuming those are stains or foxing and not ink. If dist or production ink i would say 9.0.

 

[ROBTOTHEC]

Hmm i am not sure then. The book looks structurally pretty nice. i will say 7.5/8.0 assuming those are stains or foxing and not ink. If dist or production ink i would say 9.0.

 

SO THE FINAL GRADE IS 7.5/8.0 or 9.0? I AM NO CLEARER

AS TO THE GRADE