PGM Menace 11 (b copy) - Round 2

[Johnny545]

Help me with this one. Thanks all.

 

 

[timfinz]

3.5 IMHO! I can't tell if that is a stain on the covers or shadowing? If it's water staining I'd drop the grade to 2.5!

[rjpb]

3.0

[Johnny545]

Not stained. Any one else?

[Lost]

3

[bronze johnny]

3.5 - 4.0 Nice book.

[PovertyRow]

My favorite MENACE cover. I think I'd go with the 3.5 - 4.0.

[Phill the Governor]

I'm right there with 3.5/4.0.

 

Cool book!

[comicjack]

3.5/4.0 for me great book,great cover love to have one of those!

[PovertyRow]

It's even better when you look at it upside down and get a good look at the expression on his face, especially the eyes. Right side up they look kind of sleepy sad and upside down they are terrified.

[jimjum12]

3.0 .... GOD BLESS....

 

-jimbo(a friend of jesus) (thumbs u

[Johnny545]

Round #2:

 

Is this one higher or lower or about the same as the other?

 

 

[southerncross]

2.5, rusted staples and the water damage looks like a major problem.

Love this cover, I had a chance to snag a raw pedigree copy in 8.0, 5 years ago and I'm still kicking myself for not picking it up.

[timfinz]

3.0 for your 'B' Copy IMHO!

[vaultkeeper]

3.0 Great cover! (thumbs u

[Johnny545]

2.5, rusted staples and the water damage looks like a major problem.

Love this cover, I had a chance to snag a raw pedigree copy in 8.0, 5 years ago and I'm still kicking myself for not picking it up.

 

Which pedigree?

[comicjack]

3.0 great cover indeed for the B copy

[jimjum12]

I'd prefer the "B" copy..... but still around the same grade. GOD BLESS....

 

-jimbo(a friend of jesus) (thumbs u

[PovertyRow]

I prefer the first copy. Rusted staples are a major turn-off to me (which is, of course, a purely subjective opinion). But overall I just like the appearance of the first one better.

 

I'd put the 2nd copy about .5 below the first.

[Johnny545]

Thanks all.