PGM Simpsons 1

[W16227]

 

things I see -

 

lower right cover - pin head sized white dot in the black print

 

lower left cover corner - that white dot = dust (not on comic) - but a tiny marring of the corner edge (nothing broken or ink breaks)

 

back cover- three small locations on the purple color with ink color issues

 

poster is attached - all interior sharp and good color.

 

TIA

 

 

 

cardset103012014_00000 by w16227, on Flickr

 

cardset103012014_00001 by w16227, on Flickr

 

 

[Dr_Neff]

9.2

[thunsicker]

Harsh. I'd put it at 9.4 with a off chance at 9.6.

[timfinz]

I see no reason for this copy not to get a 9.4 IMHO! Great size scans gives you a lot of detail. Take into consideration the size of the scans = 9.4

The only thing holding this back from 9.6 would be the dirt on Homer's right eye on the front cover!

If that is just on the scanner then 9.6 would be fair!

[W16227]

I see no reason for this copy not to get a 9.4 IMHO! Great size scans gives you a lot of detail. Take into consideration the size of the scans = 9.4

The only thing holding this back from 9.6 would be the dirt on Homer's right eye on the front cover!

If that is just on the scanner then 9.6 would be fair!

 

that actually is on the scanner

 

yay!

 

to all - thanks for the input on all of my scans to all- really helps to learn exactly how many little dings effect everything - a month ago I would not even have blinked on the orr purple dots - but then back then I was only slightly aware of cgc.

 

 

Is there a recommended resolution for the scans? - I do like bigger even though they get more dings - but if the general preference is smaller - I can easily adjust.

[timfinz]

I like the larger scans, say anywhere from 400 to 600 dpi. You can always make the images smaller but you can't make them larger without losing the detail. I usually put the smaller scans in the thread and give links to larger scans so as not to screw with the thread page sizing (if you know what I mean)!

9.6 because the dirt is on the scanner.

[timfinz]

Oh yeah! A very warm welcome to the boards btw! Hope you take the time to introduce yourself here:

New Members Introduce Yourselves!

Cheers!