PGM Batman: Harley & Ivy GN/TPB

[juggernaut]

Need a little help grading this. Thanks.

 

 

[timfinz]

9.0 IMHO! The top and bottom corners on the spine side are killers!

But that is only one opinion!

[divad]

Titillating, nonetheless.

[divad]

I think you need to grade TPB's slightly different for a couple of reasons. One, corner chips are more common due to the weight of the book, and two, I think you can take out the interim grades, and use the basics NM (Unread) VF/NM, VF, FN, VG. Below VF are seriously only readers, but still worthwhile readers! The cover crease is built in, and will crack with any reading.

 

Here you have the two corner chips and one small stain on the BC at "Again!" It appears to be otherwise unread. VF/NM is a safe bet, with NM a reach.

 

CGC doesn't slab these, do they? I wonder what the page limit is for slabs - 100?

[juggernaut]

I think you need to grade TPB's slightly different for a couple of reasons. One, corner chips are more common due to the weight of the book, and two, I think you can take out the interim grades, and use the basics NM (Unread) VF/NM, VF, FN, VG. Below VF are seriously only readers, but still worthwhile readers! The cover crease is built in, and will crack with any reading.

 

Here you have the two corner chips and one small stain on the BC at "Again!" It appears to be otherwise unread. VF/NM is a safe bet, with NM a reach.

 

CGC doesn't slab these, do they? I wonder what the page limit is for slabs - 100?

 

It is not a stain near "again" . It is a common defect or mark on all Batman: Harley & Ivy GN/TPB's.

[SuperDragon]

8.5-9.0

[divad]

I think you need to grade TPB's slightly different for a couple of reasons. One, corner chips are more common due to the weight of the book, and two, I think you can take out the interim grades, and use the basics NM (Unread) VF/NM, VF, FN, VG. Below VF are seriously only readers, but still worthwhile readers! The cover crease is built in, and will crack with any reading.

 

Here you have the two corner chips and one small stain on the BC at "Again!" It appears to be otherwise unread. VF/NM is a safe bet, with NM a reach.

 

CGC doesn't slab these, do they? I wonder what the page limit is for slabs - 100?

 

It is not a stain near "again" . It is a common defect or mark on all Batman: Harley & Ivy GN/TPB's.

 

Cool, then I'm fine with a NM. (thumbs u

[fastballspecial]

9.0 back cover corner kills higher I think. Id like to know if you get it grades as I have never seen that defect graded yet.