PGM: Fantastic Four 48

[loboagain]

Grades and thoughts please. Thanks!

 

[DavidTheDavid]

6.0 with that crease on the top left front. Is that a tear on the back, maybe two inches off the right edge? 5.5 with that, I'd guess.

[loboagain]

6.0 with that crease on the top left front. Is that a tear on the back, maybe two inches off the right edge? 5.5 with that, I'd guess.

 

Its a small tear, about 1/8 the rest are all spine stress on the back.

[timfinz]

5.5 IMHO! But larger scans will hurt my eyes less!

[vaillant]

I agree with David’s FN (6.0), maybe even a bit better if the cover lies flat: book is otherwise pretty nice and the large crease is consistent with the FN/FN+ grade… (thumbs u

 

Love the copy Lobo, I am envious…

[DR.X]

The size of that crease is substantial. I'm more in the 5.5 area but ........?

[DavidTheDavid]

The size of that crease is substantial. I'm more in the 5.5 area but ........?

I went with 6.0 despite that crease based on this FF 13 I just bought. So I guess that was my 'what CGC will call this' grade.

 

FF 13 below for OP's reference.

 

 

 

[vaillant]

DR.X is right, as the crease is pretty long, but I still do think that, being the book overall nice it has a good shot at a full FN. In the worst of cases, a nice FN-, IMO. (thumbs u

 

P.S. Your #13 is beautiful, David!

[Mijael.Levy]

6.5 IMO