PGM: Our Army at War #217

[JollyComics]

Please grade this book for me.

 

Any questions regarding this book will be answered. *There is a hairline on the scanner - not the book.*

 

Once your give me estimated grades, I will give my estimated grade too.

 

I have 6 more OAAW books coming. Please grade all other books for me too.

 

Thanks buddies!

 

 

 

 

[Jeffro.]

8.0, maybe 7.5

 

Is there a stain back cover upper right corner?

[Vision75]

8.0, maybe 7.5

 

Is there a stain back cover upper right corner?

 

Right there with Jeffro. Thinking a weakish 8.0 or a strong 7.5:

 

*Several minor spine ticks.

*Minor blunting around all corners.

*Slight damage on middle of right edge fc

 

Overall, presents well. Nice book.

 

 

[timfinz]

7.0 IMHO! I have the same defects that are pointed out by Vision75 and the possible stain by Jeffro. But I am also seeing a slight dust shadow along the spine on the back cover which incidentally shows more spine wear than the front cover.

 

Again if the corners on this book were sharper I would have bumped this grade by .5 but that's just my opinion.

[JollyComics]

Hi Jeffro - that is a scuff that has been smudged with dirt. It can be removed easily.

 

To my Vision75 - two out of four corners have minor blunting. Yes there is a thumb crease that broke the color.

 

Timern - speaking of the dust shadow, there is very small fainting dust shadow at the top spine corner. I checked it under the light. It is almost unseen that would be a hidden defect. All along the spine, there is no dust shadow. The color is slightly cream on the back cover due to the age.

[tjanse]

7.5

[DavidTheDavid]

7.5

[JollyComics]

7.5 sounds a right logic. It is about the same as you.