CGC Grades the WRONG BOOK - And It's A KEY!!!

[retrothecollector]

Who's Maslow, somebody's mom, and slow? What'd I miss?

 

 

I'm not mad at CGC, they just graded four of mine with the coupon, in 20 total days. Three upgraded, plus two went to White pages.

 

We'll see what the labels say.

It's gonna say First App and "death" of IBTL

 

 

BOOM!!

[rtecbot]

So somewhere out there is an ASM 1 with an annual label on it? Hopefully the grade is the same

[Columbia Comics]

Did someone say points?

[A.Romeo]

these are magical times we live in

[HarveySwick]

[yoddler]

How is this still here? GLWTS!

[Gotham Kid]

[Gotham Kid]

good luck with the no-sale !

[The-Collector]

Sell the label, not the book

 

 

 

[Bomber-Bob]

I sent in my ASM ANNUAL #1 (standard service) and today it came back -

Marked AMAZING SPIDERMAN #1?

I could see an error like this for some obscure Golden Age, but this is a damn KEY book which I kinda think they have seen before? So much for "quality control"

 

 

It's a mistake, no big deal, CGC will fix it for you. Why are you coming here to complain, what do you want to accomplish ?

[ComicDoc]

Make a video tape of you opening it - make sure you act completely surprised that it is not Amazing Spiderman #1 and post it on youtube.

[Buzzetta]

Seems to be the place to post anything these days...

 

 

In all seriousness, is it for sale?

 

if not then you should contact CGC to send it back and get it fixed.

 

 

 

[lizards2]

[Designer Toast]

Make a video tape of you opening it - make sure you act completely surprised that it is not Amazing Spiderman #1 and post it on youtube.

 

[Tony S]

It is rather ironic that you're complaining about the wrong label in the wrong forum.

 

+1.

[MediumLover]

[Designer Toast]

Is this mod appreciation week? Looks like there isn't anyone home...

[Hibou]

I sent in my ASM ANNUAL #1 (standard service) and today it came back -

Marked AMAZING SPIDERMAN #1?

I could see an error like this for some obscure Golden Age, but this is a damn KEY book which I kinda think they have seen before? So much for "quality control"

 

...

Ok so it's only my second batch to be graded - but does this happen often?

 

So by now you've realized that this is the sales section and if you're looking to sell it, then (by CGC board rules) you must list a price. I'm figuring you're just pointing out a mistake so the thread probably should be placed in CG (Comics General).

 

I'm curious what the rest of the book looks like for it to be a 3.0.

 

Anyways, to answer your question... it happens from time to time but not normally.

[MediumLover]

[southerncross]

I sent in my ASM ANNUAL #1 (standard service) and today it came back -

Marked AMAZING SPIDERMAN #1?

I could see an error like this for some obscure Golden Age, but this is a damn KEY book which I kinda think they have seen before? So much for "quality control"

 

...

Ok so it's only my second batch to be graded - but does this happen often?

 

 

 

sell it on e-bay list it spiderman 1 cgc