CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest Round 6

[thunsicker]

Wow! All those 8's for the others and I couldn't figure out what was going on in the upper back corner of the Mad, I bumped it right into a -1.

 

toro got a -1!

[oakman29]

I still think that Mad #1 is an 8.0

[Jester Hats]

The Mad looked like it had chips out of the back cover spine. Guess I was wrong.

[JazzMan]

Double bulls for me!

[AJD]

I still think that Mad #1 is an 8.0

 

Not even close - look at the outer edge of the back cover and the edge tear on the front. I had it at 6.5 but was debating 7.0

[porky]

grrrr.

 

CGC doesn't see the same comics i see...........

[toro]

Wow! All those 8's for the others and I couldn't figure out what was going on in the upper back corner of the Mad, I bumped it right into a -1.

 

toro got a -1!

 

I do get those from time to time.

[wasteddraftpicks]

That Mad looks to have a small spine split at the top, and the tears around the staples are a bit too severe for an 8.0 IMO. I thought about an 8, but those things combined made me knock it down a grade....not down quite enough, though.

[jaybuck43]

I had the Mad at a 7.5. It really is gorgeous. Regrade!!

[Hibou]

Not bad, 1 off, 1 bullseye

 

Not bad for me either. CGC got one bullseye and got one 1 grade off.

 

Same here as well...

[Chip Cataldo]

No way is that Harbinger a 9.8.

 

Peace,

 

Chip

[Awax]

I'm in the running for last.

 

But I did get a bullseye .. I'm better on moderns.

 

It's going to be sad that some that don't even play every round will have more points than I.

 

But, I'm sticking around till the end.

[sckao]

 

Results are up!

 

http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=7858962#Post7858962

 

 

[NinjaSealed]

I really hate grading between 9.6/9.8 books. Harbinger #2 looked 9.6 to me. Oh well.

 

Mad #1 wasn't too bad. Was better than a 6.5 and definitely not an 8.0, pretty easy F/VF with the wear it had IMO.