Spidey 51 Grade?

[nik]

What do you members think?

[Murph]

VF

[divad]

*** You are ignoring this user ***

[divad]

Niko, Do you know the provenance? So sharp, I'd suspect trimming How's the PQ?

If it's not overly tanned, it's easily a 9.0

Show us the back, and I might even go a bit higher . . .

[nik]

Forgot to scan the back , but the back cover is very sharp. PQ is I think Cream/OW, and yeah I have bought from this person before. The edges are very sharp on the book, trimming? I sure hope not

 

My buddy and I have this as a VF/NM in mind, but what the heck do I know about grading

[burntboy]

i'm thinking 8.5 due to the very fine crease in the ULC right into spidey's eye in the logo, maybe 4 very small spine nicks, the LRC crease and the squiggly crease on spidey's .........

 

nice book..........

[divad]

[LastStarfighter]

I think 7.5 actually. Crease at bottom right corner, stress around bottom staple, some kind of pressure wave crease at Spidey's leg, and 1/2" crease at upper left corner. And that's without seeing the back...Colors are very bold and bright. Top edge looks like it has a very slight ding and bottom left edge looks slightly rough. At best an 8.0.

[divad]

I think 7.5 actually. Crease at bottom right corner, stress around bottom staple, some kind of pressure wave crease at Spidey's leg, and 1/2" crease at upper left corner. And that's without seeing the back...Colors are very bold and bright. Top edge looks like it has a very slight ding and bottom left edge looks slightly rough. At best an 8.0.

 

LSF - Please immediately box up ALL of your 7.5 SA Spidey's and send them directly to me. I will pay you full guide for your troubles!

 

Besides, no one really wants those damn minus grades in their collection - nothing but a black mark on the rest of your books!!!

[arexcrooke]

I think 7.5 actually. Crease at bottom right corner, stress around bottom staple, some kind of pressure wave crease at Spidey's leg, and 1/2" crease at upper left corner. And that's without seeing the back...Colors are very bold and bright. Top edge looks like it has a very slight ding and bottom left edge looks slightly rough. At best an 8.0.

 

LSF - Please immediately box up ALL of your 7.5 SA Spidey's and send them directly to me. I will pay you full guide for your troubles!

 

Besides, no one really wants those damn minus grades in their collection - nothing but a black mark on the rest of your books!!!

 

[LastStarfighter]

Sorry I don't get it?

[LastStarfighter]

Did you win this book off of ebay recently?

[divad]

Did you win this book off of ebay recently?

 

If you have to ask . . .

[LastStarfighter]

Just because I think I bid on it too.

[divad]

Just because I think I bid on it too.

 

You should have bid higher!

[nik]

Just because I think I bid on it too.

 

Let me clear the air for you here, you definately did not bid on this one this was never on Ebay.

[divad]

[12c_Comic]

strong spine ,I would give that copy a 8.5 to a 9.0

[Kramerica]

8.0-8.5

[sfilosa]

I'm saying 8.0 to 8.5 (but looks a little nicer).

 

Upper corners both have wear. Lower left has small, but full corner crease. Plus some spine wear.