PGM Aquaman #1, fire trolls! EDIT: Now back from CGC

[He11blazer]

I really like this cover. Early silver age superheroes, but those trolls have a real pre-hero vibe

 

 

A better look at that spine / left edge:

 

 

Back scan and a few photos in a moment...

[He11blazer]

 

Scan makes it look dirty. It's not at all. Photo shows the colour more accurately.

 

[He11blazer]

 

 

[paul747]

Nice book... 6.5/ with that CB spine line cracking

[He11blazer]

Nice book... 6.5/ with that CB spine line cracking

 

That's definitely the stand out issue when you look at the scan. I'm looking it over thinking it might be worthy of a 6.5, with 6.0 as my baseline. As in, whatever I end up deciding, this has to be a 6.0 absolute minimum.

 

I'm thinking of sending it the way of the slab.

[Topnotchman]

I agree with a 6.5 with the reading crease along the spine.

[NuffSaid57]

Cool cover. 6.5 seems about right with the stress along the spine.

[He11blazer]

For those it may interest, this just came back from CGC

 

[bighairjer]

Nice!