PGM EERIE 1 GRADE IN

[The-Collector]

Opinions much appreciated.

 

 

 

[oakman29]

Ted at Superworld had an awesome copy of this book at Wonder con yesterday.

[The-Collector]

Ted at Superworld had an awesome copy of this book at Wonder con yesterday.

 

Raw or graded? It is definitely a very cool book.

 

What is your opinion on this one Oak?

[oakman29]

Ted at Superworld had an awesome copy of this book at Wonder con yesterday.

 

Raw or graded? It is definitely a very cool book.

 

What is your opinion on this one Oak?

 

I say it's in that 4.5 range,very nice book.

[kav]

Yeah 4.5 and

Nice comic

[Ghost Rider]

4.5 But 5.0 isn't that far off either. Cool Book.

[piper]

Is it for sale?

[Johnny545]

5.5

[Wilson3d]

My first thought was a 6.0. Maybe that is just too high and 5.5 is closer. I feel like in the Thirdgreenham grading contests of the last few years, one thing I kept missing on was grading the 10 centers and the 12 centers the same. I undergraded all the GA books because I was holding them to the same standards as any other era books. Seems like they get a away with more.

[Wilson3d]

Also - WOW, what an amazing cover!

[bighairjer]

Great book, 5.5 or better with a squish. Yours?

[The-Collector]

Great book, 5.5 or better with a squish. Yours?

 

Yep it is mine now

[The-Collector]

Is it for sale?

 

I had bought to keep, not really looking to sell.

[piper]

4.5

[The-Collector]

Grade is now in if anyone wants to guess.

[Johnny545]

6.0

[The-Collector]

I should say that I think the dark area along the back is not actually darker that is just the scan from where the books falls away from contacting the scanner bed.

[The-Collector]

Grade is:

 

 

8.5 :banana: :banana: 3rd highest grade on the first all horror comic book

 

[wombat]

Awesome book.

[KDUK]

Awesome

 

Did not have that as an 8.5 - congrats