Please grade this Monster of Frankenstein #2 - Classic Mike Ploog!

[divad]

Defects are pretty much how you see them - look closely now!

 

PQ doesn't get any better - deep in the tomato boxes . . .

 

 

 

 

[nik]

Tiny chip BRFC, Top right corner crease that breaks color, I cant make out whats on the bottom edge under the letter S?

Great colors, final grade 9.0

[comicdonna]

No color break allowed in the bend to make a 9.0. Still, a great looking book. I'll give it a 8.5

[nik]

No color break allowed in the bend to make a 9.0. Still, a great looking book. I'll give it a 8.5

[comicdonna]

Thats a nice book. Don't you agree that the bend in your book is smaller than the book we are grading?

[FFB]

I think that the 1-inch tear on the bottom edge and stain at the base of the tear, along with the upper right corner crease, spine stress, abraded ULC, and chip out of the LRC knocks this down to about 6.0. Without the tear and stain at the bottom, I could see 8.0.

 

9.0?

[comicdonna]

I didn't see the tear. That would make a Big difference.

[nik]

I think that the 1-inch tear on the bottom edge and stain at the base of the tear, along with the upper right corner crease, spine stress, abraded ULC, and chip out of the LRC knocks this down to about 6.0. Without the tear and stain at the bottom, I could see 8.0.

 

9.0?

I didnt think that was a tear

Damn thats twice today I got the looney signal

[Artboy99]

Upper right corner bend, Lower rc bash, lower center crinkle

stain/ dirt blob lower center and far to many spine crinkles ( even tho they minor ) for me to see this any higher than 7.0

 

Artboy99

[divad]

I think that the 1-inch tear on the bottom edge and stain at the base of the tear, along with the upper right corner crease, spine stress, abraded ULC, and chip out of the LRC knocks this down to about 6.0. Without the tear and stain at the bottom, I could see 8.0.

 

9.0?

 

Whew! Scott - NO tear, more like a little cover crinkle - good eye on the little stain there though. 6.0? I don't think so, but hey . . .

 

(I am not my books - repeat - I am not my books - repeat)

 

[divad]

Thats a nice book. Don't you agree that the bend in your book is smaller than the book we are grading?

 

Now they're bends? They're creases! Don't pussyfoot around!

[divad]

I think that the 1-inch tear on the bottom edge and stain at the base of the tear, along with the upper right corner crease, spine stress, abraded ULC, and chip out of the LRC knocks this down to about 6.0. Without the tear and stain at the bottom, I could see 8.0.

 

9.0?

I didnt think that was a tear

Damn thats twice today I got the looney signal

 

Absolutely NO tear (even if if it kinda' looks like one )

[divad]

Upper right corner bend, Lower rc bash, lower center crinkle

stain/ dirt blob lower center and far to many spine crinkles ( even tho they minor ) for me to see this any higher than 7.0

 

Artboy99

 

Damn straight! I'll think I'll line the kitty box with it!

[divad]

Just paid you Bro!

[awe4one]

8.5

 

Jim

[Artboy99]

AWWW Diva,

I didnt mean to insult your book!

Please dont line the kitty litter with it.

I grade it 7.0. That still is VF isnt it?

 

Artboy99

[burntboy]

i thought that was a tear as well, but since it's not, i'm thinking 7.0 - 7.5. i count at least a dozen color breaking tiny spine nicks. the LRC has a small chip out and that crinkly crease with the mild stain all add up. still, it presents very nicely...

[divad]

i thought that was a tear as well, but since it's not, i'm thinking 7.0 - 7.5. i count at least a dozen color breaking tiny spine nicks. the LRC has a small chip out and that crinkly crease with the mild stain all add up. still, it presents very nicely...

 

[Sal]

i was thinking 8.0. but of course this is akin to asking your gramma what that funny noise your HDD is making.

 

i based that score on the bend in the URFC, the stain, the wee chip out of the LRFC and the creases on the spine. colours look excellent and bright, tho