PGM Thor 151

[Cherubim]

For full disclosure, one staple has a tiny square-ish less than 1/16" piece detached from around it (actually still have the piece in the bag but I know that doesn't matter). Per Overstreet, sounds like that would keep this book out of anything higher than VG+, but man it looks great otherwise. So does that one tiny missing piece keep the grade that low or is it higher? Thank you for your thoughts!

 

Front Cover

 

Back Cover

 

Missing piece

[SweetComic]

I don't believe that defect would hold it in the VG range from what I can see. Small tears are allowed in the FN ranges also depending on the severity.

[Cherubim]

Ok, thanks for the feedback. I have trouble fully understanding the Overstreet guide as they often say things like "no missing pieces" for various grades, which to me implies the comic can't be at that grade even if pretty much everything else about it fits or exceeds a specific grade.

[ivegotneatstuff]

4.5