MARCH CONTEST : Round 2 : Triple OT

[nik]

Off-white, new label,this round is for :

 

#55 scrooge vs #43 ares

 

#29 norrin radd vs. #63 supremo

 

#23 143ksk vs. #20 blutobc

 

[nik]

[Jayman]

Quit dodging those bullets!

 

[Norrin_Radd]

Quit dodging those bullets!

 

 

Tell that to Supremo!

[Ares]

Scrooge is Tenacious as well

[Sal]

not one of BWS's better efforts, that cover. Thor's cape, his hammer, that ridiculous outfit hawkeye's wearing...

 

and i LOVE Barry Windsor-Smith. but that's just not very good.

 

 

good luck!

[Red Hook]

I agree on the BWS cover. A real let down for a 100th issue. I blame Bendis.

[blutobc]

PM grade sent

 

There's no way I'll tie this time.

 

I took my initial guess...

- multiplied it by 4

- added 10 to that

- then divided by 3

- subtracted 2

- integrated that number to the nth degree

- then conjugated it into a verb

 

finally I just through all of that into the trash and pulled a number out of my Butt and PMed it in. So don't touch my guess too much nikos.

[Scrooge]

Ares,

 

let me tell you that prospecting in the Yukon does develop one's stamina. Haven't had this much fun since I was herding cattle in the badlands with that buckaroo of Teddy Roosevelt!

 

Scrooge (in character)

[143ksk]

PM grade sent

 

There's no way I'll tie this time.

 

I took my initial guess...

- multiplied it by 4

- added 10 to that

- then divided by 3

- subtracted 2

- integrated that number to the nth degree

- then conjugated it into a verb

 

finally I just through all of that into the trash and pulled a number out of my Butt and PMed it in. So don't touch my guess too much nikos.

 

Wow, that's what I did, too! Well, except the butt part

[namisgr]

not one of BWS's better efforts, that cover. Thor's cape, his hammer, that ridiculous outfit hawkeye's wearing...

 

and i LOVE Barry Windsor-Smith. but that's just not very good!

 

The amazing thing is, this book has one of my alltime favorite splash pages. BWS did a gorgeous rendering of the Black Knight and Aragorn in the process of landing on page 1. Must've been where all his drawing energies were focused...

[Sal]

maybe vince colletta did an uncredited inking job on it. that would explain a lot, as far as i am concerned.

 

unless Red's right and it really was bendis's fault, which as we all know, is highly likely

[blutobc]

Just got an emergency call to go and clean up a gasoline spill - if this goes into a 4th round I'll probably be busy until tomorrow morning. So talk about me all you like, but I won't hear it.

[Ze-man]

maybe vince colletta did an uncredited inking job on it. that would explain a lot, as far as i am concerned.

 

unless Red's right and it really was bendis's fault, which as we all know, is highly likely

 

 

What..? so nobody liked the inking on Iron Man's new prototype pinstripe right leg armor?

Or the new Shaggy Hulk?

 

Tuff crowd.

 

Ze-

[Zonker]

The amazing thing is, this book has one of my alltime favorite splash pages. BWS did a gorgeous rendering of the Black Knight and Aragorn in the process of landing on page 1. Must've been where all his drawing energies were focused...

 

The interiors are indeed nice!

 

 

...but why was the Hulk wearing his Beatle wig in this issue?

[Red Hook]

I personally think the back cover is going to be tough to grade.....hidden flaws and all.

 

[Ares]

I personally think the back cover is going to be tough to grade.....hidden flaws and all.

 

[burntboy]

not one of BWS's better efforts, that cover. Thor's cape, his hammer, that ridiculous outfit hawkeye's wearing...

 

and i LOVE Barry Windsor-Smith. but that's just not very good.

 

 

good luck!

 

 

you don't like Hawkeye's skirt????

[Sal]

not one of BWS's better efforts, that cover. Thor's cape, his hammer, that ridiculous outfit hawkeye's wearing...

 

and i LOVE Barry Windsor-Smith. but that's just not very good.

 

 

good luck!

 

 

you don't like Hawkeye's skirt????

 

it'th purrty. and it looks like he's about to skewer thor in the knee.

 

actually, the olivia newton-john-esque headband is what really makes me nervous. that and aragorn's eye, which is boring a path straight through my occipital nerve, which may or may not be an actual part of human anatomy

[Aces]

#55 scrooge vs #43 ares

 

#29 norrin radd vs. #63 supremo

 

#23 143ksk vs. #20 blutobc

 

So did these six folks get their grades in yet...