2015 CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest- Round 3 Results

[sckao]

 

 

2015 CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest Round 3 Results

 

 

BK 1: Fantastic Four 46 Cream to Off White Pages - Actual Grade: 6.0

 

BK 2: Superman 32 Off-White to White Pages - Actual Grade: 3.5

 

Link to Books and Scans

 

Round 3 Grade Breakdowns

 

 

2013 Grading Contest: Round 3 Results - Leader Board

 

[sckao]

 

2015 Grading Contest - Individual Achievements for Round 3

 

 

[sckao]

 

 

2015 Grading Contest - Place by Round

 

[sckao]

 

2015 Grading Contest: Results So Far - OVER/UNDER

 

[sckao]

 

Round 3 COMMENTARY

 

 

 

One word sums up this round: CARNAGE!!!

 

Congrats to 427Impaler for surviving and ascending to FIRST PLACE!

 

Only a scant two were able to attain the magical Double Bullseyes this round, 427Impaler and snowman28!

 

Back to Game 6. Onwards to ROUND 4!

 

 

[Tivo32]

Not a bad round for me! I'll take 4 points!

[sckao]

Breakdown chart is wrong...I'll fix it later (FIXED)

 

[Scturo]

I learn more from one bomb, than 5 bullseyes,

[Noodlez]

Dang...73 to 28th?

 

I guess my wife was wrong about about me.

[thunsicker]

Over two thirds of the people got an-1 on that FF.

 

EDIT: make that 82%.

[01TheDude]

Not a bad round for me! I'll take 4 points!

 

me too - 4 points.

 

I should have went with my gut guess of 3.5 on the Supes but I have a problem nailing GA in general so I took the safe pick. The FF must have had more tanning than could be seen as it seemed VERY nice on the cover and the main issue seemed to be that back cover tanning. Could be both interior covers had that tanning issue. When I hear lots of people whining about how tough this round is, I think it impacts my willingness to hit a bullseye versus hit the range.

[Azkaban]

[*Bronze age fan*]

On an unrelated note.....the board savior Swick missed two rounds??? Anyone posts a new book in any of HIS club threads he welcomes then within three minutes.

 

Banana time.

[Senormac]

[kav]

well i cant complain i guess i moved up 2 notches

[thunsicker]

If there's any consolation I avoided having the mods notified on me. Barely.

[Spyder!]

Really? I nailed the Supes and was way way off on the FF? Totally the opposite of what I expected. That FF was meant to screw with everyone.

[trmoore54]

Over two thirds of the people got an-1 on that FF.

 

EDIT: make that 82%.

 

Including the guy who bought it!!

[sckao]

 

NOTE:

UncannyX-Force actually had 2 THREE POINT scores for a total of SIX POINTS for ROUND 3. We regret the error.

 

 

[stanley1883]

WOW CGC dropped the ball on that. over 82% "were wrong?" Wow, I can't believe that. Great book for the contest though, definitely thins the herd, and basically eliminated me.