Guess the Grade: Ghosts #41 -- New Fast Loading Scans

[sterlingcomics]

Looks like dings on all four corners of some time (although mild) and a handling defect at the top (around the DC moniker). What say you?

 

These are the new and improved scans--lmk if they load fast enough and have enough detail!

 

 

[DiceX]

8.0

 

This scan loaded faster.

The others took about a second. These loaded in about a half second.

(I love cable internet!)

[sterlingcomics]

I tend to agree. Would you believe a dealer said this was a NM/NM+?

[Aces]

8.0/8.5

 

"guess the grade"

 

Are these at CGC?

[Aces]

I tend to agree. Would you believe a dealer said this was a NM/NM+?

 

YES!

[sterlingcomics]

8.0/8.5

 

"guess the grade"

 

Are these at CGC?

 

NO! GOING BACK TO DEALER!

[sterlingcomics]

I tend to agree. Would you believe a dealer said this was a NM/NM+?

 

YES!

 

I think I'm going to start a thread that compares dealer's grades and the CGC grade. If nothing else, for leverage for those demanding accurate grades.

[sterlingcomics]

8.0/8.5

 

"guess the grade"

 

Are these at CGC?

 

More specifically, I wanted you, the experts, to provide justification to what I thought was inaccurate grading. And Aces and DiceX, I know your grading is good, so I highly respect your opinion.

[DiceX]

Would you believe a dealer said this was a NM/NM+?

 

Yes.

[nik]

I think its in the 8.5/9.0 range.