2016 Green Eggs Grading Contest- Round 6

[thirdgreenham]

Book 11: Krazy Komics #1 CGC 7.5

 

 

Book 12: Chamber of Chills #24 CGC 6.0

 

 

[1Cool]

Well there goes my streak of under grading everything. Thought Golden Age books got a nice bump so I went 8.0 and 7.0.

[grebal]

That's okay, Andy, your buyers know you're a tight grader.

 

I went 7.0 on the Krazy, and I thought that was overgrading on account of the tape pull. Thus endeth my nice streak that lasted all of 1 round.

[trmoore54]

Went 7.0/6.5...I'll take it...3/3...woot!!

[Hado]

Way low on the Krazy.

 

I thought the tape pull would really bring it down.

[porcupine48]

boobs

[jcjames]

[thirdgreenham]

This is why I like submitting books like that Krazy; learning what they would take off for a tape pull like that. Astoundingly, it looks like only .5 off.

[01TheDude]

Way low on the Krazy.

 

I thought the tape pull would really bring it down.

 

I initially thought it was a tape pull as well but the longer I looked at it, the more I thought it was a production defect.

[1Cool]

I don't remember seeing a tape pull

 

Of course now I see it - doesn't really matter since I'd have probably gone 7.0 and still gotten 3 points

[Ken Aldred]

I'm doing well.

[jcjames]

All those small tears on the Chamber cover... wow. Punishing undergrase this time.

[Ron C.]

I said 8.0/5.5. Not bad for this round, but can't seem to get a bullseye. After all my 3's and -1's, my wife will insist I sit down to pee.

[thirdgreenham]

[IncredibleHauck]

I can't believe that the Krazy Komics got a 7.5 . I thought that Tape Pull would have brought it down to a 5.0 or 6.0 best

[thirdgreenham]

Shin will get the results thread up sometime tonight. I'm going to go ahead and create round 7 now.

[Azkaban]

A 7.5 that's Krazy

[Ron Rau]

Hi 3rd.

Would you say that things are changing at CGC - where overall they're really easing up on defects like a tape pull of this magnitude, or do you think it's just an anomaly?

 

Thanks!

[krighton]

ugh, 6.0 and 4.5...i'm grading way too low...I need to start thinking more like CGC

[aszumilo]

I kept debating between a 7.0 and 7.5 on the Krazy. I chose wrong.