2016 Green Eggs Grading Contest- Round 6

[letsgrumble]

 

 

Looks like the guy is losing his bowler hat over the tape pull.

 

I gave it a 6.0 grade thinking I'd at least be close.

[Plantman]

Wow, I slaughtered these books and hence got slaughtered myself.

 

I gave the Krazy a 5.0. Not only did I kill it for the tape pull I thought the spine splits would have hit it hard too.

 

Went 4.5 on the Chamber. Too many tears. I thought maybe a 5.0 but certainly not a 5.5. Wow was I off.

 

I had the Krazy at 7.5 without considering the tape pull because of those spine splits, and that included a golden age bump. I thought a tape pull that bad would knock it down to at best a 6.0 grade.

[Comicdey]

I graded so fast I didn't even see most the defects. :-)

[Iceman399]

Andy any chance you have the notes on the krazy?

[grebal]

I graded so fast I didn't even see most the defects. :-)

 

I'm still pretty new here but I think I recall reading it in old thread - didn't you win last year? Or place near the top?

[Wilson3d]

Yeah, I had Krazy Komics #1 at a 6.5 for the golden age bump. A 7.5 really is Krazy!

[1Cool]

I graded so fast I didn't even see most the defects. :-)

 

I'm still pretty new here but I think I recall reading it in old thread - didn't you win last year? Or place near the top?

 

Comicdey is a great grader - had the misfortune of going up against him in one of the other grading contest. Killed me.