2016 CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest - Round 9 Results

[sckao]

 

2016 CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest Round 9 (of 10) Results

 

 

BK 17: ASM #3 Off-White Pages - Actual Grade: 7.5

 

BK 18: ASM #13 Off-White Pages - Actual Grade: 7.5

 

Link to Books and Scans

 

 

 

Round 9 Grade Breakdowns

 

 

 

 

2016 Grading Contest: Round 9 Results - Leader Board

 

 

Grading Contest Books:

01. Our Army At War #84 (DC)

02. The Walking Dead #1 (Image)

03. Star Spangled War Stories #90 (DC)

04. Famous Funnies #207 (Eastern Color)

05. Unseen #10 Off-White to White Pages (Standard Comics)

06. Fantastic Comics #5 Brittle Pages **cover detached** (Fox Features)

07. Poe Dameron #1 Action Figure Sketch Cover- White Pages (Marvel)

08. Future Comics #2 Off-White Pages (David McKay Publishing)

09. Amazing Spider-Man #104 Off-White to White Pages (Marvel)

10. Detective Comics #441 Off-White to White Pages (DC)

11. Krazy Komics #1 Off-White to White Pages (Timely Comics)

12. Chamber of Chills #24 Off-White Pages (Harvey Publications)

13. Showcase #35 Off-White Pages (DC)

14. Unexpected #105 Off-White Pages (DC)

15. Batman Adventures #12 - white pages (DC)

16. The Crow #1 - white pages (Caliber)

17. ASM #3 - Off-White Pages (Marvel)

18. ASM #13 - Off-White Pages (Marvel)

[sckao]

 

2016 Grading Contest - Individual Achievements for Round 9

 

 

[sckao]

 

2016 Grading Contest - Place by Round

 

 

[sckao]

 

Round 9 COMMENTARY

 

With one round to go, there is now a four-way tie for FIRST PLACE. Who blinks first?

 

 

 

Congrats to the four double bullseyes... old_dano, iceman399, Red_Hood, and Jeffreykli!

 

In the end, there can be ONLY ONE!

 

[thirdgreenham]

[MetalPSI]

One of the best scenes in cinematic history

[marmat]

And what a soundtrack

[B2D327]

anyone know how Lee Van Cleef lost his fingertip?

[MediumLover]

Blondieee!

[Nick's Comics]

This is in my top 5 favorite movies of all time.

[sckao]

Round 9 COMMENTARY

 

With one round to go, there is now a four-way tie for FIRST PLACE. Who blinks first?

 

 

 

Congrats to the four double bullseyes... grebal, iceman399, Red_Hood, and Jeffreykli!

 

In the end, there can be ONLY ONE!

 

unless I am reading this wrong, wasn't old_dano the one who had the double bull, not grebal?

 

Oops. Too late and too many little numbers...

[fastballspecial]

Someone break down the defects on the ASM books I didn't see. I didn't pay attention I thought they were nicer.

 

[Chaseman210]

Man, .5 off of having double bullseye.

[thirdgreenham]

[WEBHEAD]

Someone break down the defects on the ASM books I didn't see. I didn't pay attention I thought they were nicer.

 

 

WT (Fudge) I agree I looked carefully and used Overstreets most recent grading book, where are the hidden defect. There were gift grades on some and real misses on these as far as I could see.

 

CGC grading is waco they need to let the grading notes be available to all because they are so inconstant .

[TheLiamSturgess]

Someone break down the defects on the ASM books I didn't see. I didn't pay attention I thought they were nicer.

 

 

WT (Fudge) I agree I looked carefully and used Overstreets most recent grading book, where are the hidden defect. There were gift grades on some and real misses on these as far as I could see.

 

CGC grading is waco they need to let the grading notes be available to all because they are so inconstant .

 

I'm not sure trying to use the Overstreet grading book was the solution - CGC doesn't necessarily follow their standards. I agree that the grading was a little wacky in a couple cases but I don't think the comparison is fair.

[Red84]

I'm looking for a big final round to move into the prize pool!

[ninanina]

I'm looking for a big final round to avoid any further embarrassment.

[Ken Aldred]

I'll be disappointed if someone robs me of last place, especially after all of the effort which I've invested in avoiding lenient, gift grading.

[Mio]

Is there a prize for the biggest collapse after having double bullseyes in the first round?