2016 CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest - FINAL RANKINGS

[guldanaaron]

FANTASY RANKINGS - DCs ONLY (For Speculation Only)

 

What if we only tabulated the DC books? That would leave six books:

 

Grading Contest Books:

01. Our Army At War #84 (DC)

03. Star Spangled War Stories #90 (DC)

10. Detective Comics #441 Off-White to White Pages (DC)

13. Showcase #35 Off-White Pages (DC)

14. Unexpected #105 Off-White Pages (DC)

15. Batman Adventures #12 - white pages (DC)

 

 

Well I guess im a expert DC grader?

[sterlingcomics]

Yeah I tended to grade DC books more accurately. I'm an equal opportunity over/under participant.

[Chillax23]

Woot - just squeaked in a top 25 finish

 

I didn't know what to expect for my first crack at this, but overall pleasantly surprised

 

Great contest guys and thanks for organizing

[*Bronze age fan*]

FANTASY RANKINGS - MARVELS ONLY (For Speculation Only)

 

What if we only tabulated the MARVEL books? That would leave six books:

 

Grading Contest Books:

07. Poe Dameron #1 Action Figure Sketch Cover- White Pages (Marvel)

09. Amazing Spider-Man #104 Off-White to White Pages (Marvel)

17. ASM #3 - Off-White Pages (Marvel)

18. ASM #13 - Off-White Pages (Marvel)

19. Avengers 57 Off-White to White Pages (Marvel)

20. Daredevil #1 Off-White Pages (Marvel)

 

 

 

[KryptoMayor]

I was 11th in Marvel, 10th in DC, and 57th in all others. I guess all others don't matter to me

[Captain Canuck]

No boobie prize?

[Iceman399]

No boobie prize?

 

The mods don't like boobie prizes anymore ever since the hoola hoop girl...

[sckao]

No boobie prize?

 

Actually, you missed two rounds...

 

[thirdgreenham]

No boobie prize?

 

Yes, the booby prize went to wamh0416. He had the lowest score while submitting grades for all 10 rounds.

[joeypost]

Hopefully I will be able to participate in the next one.

[Iceman399]

Hopefully I will be able to participate in the next one.

 

haven't seen you recently. Hope all is well

[thirdgreenham]

Hopefully I will be able to participate in the next one.

 

Yeah, I hope so too, Joey!

[s14roller]

Fun contest, hope to do better next yr. Missed last 2 rounds as I was traveling this weekend...;-(

[FineCollector]

Top 20(-ish!) finish is good enough for me my first time around!

 

Where should the mystery box and booby prize winners post pictures of what they got?

[thirdgreenham]

in the prize thread, if they'd like.

[Nick's Comics]

If it's not to much trouble can we see a fantasy chart for everything except DC? If it's to much work then don't worry about it.

 

[sckao]

 

FANTASY RANKINGS - EVERYTHING BUT DC (For Speculation Only)

 

What if we only tabulated the NON-DC books? That would leave 14 books:

 

Grading Contest Books:

02. The Walking Dead #1 (Image)

04. Famous Funnies #207 (Eastern Color)

05. Unseen #10 Off-White to White Pages (Standard Comics)

06. Fantastic Comics #5 Brittle Pages **cover detached** (Fox Features)

07. Poe Dameron #1 Action Figure Sketch Cover- White Pages (Marvel)

08. Future Comics #2 Off-White Pages (David McKay Publishing)

09. Amazing Spider-Man #104 Off-White to White Pages (Marvel)

11. Krazy Komics #1 Off-White to White Pages (Timely Comics)

12. Chamber of Chills #24 Off-White Pages (Harvey Publications)

16. The Crow #1 - white pages (Caliber)

17. ASM #3 - Off-White Pages (Marvel)

18. ASM #13 - Off-White Pages (Marvel)

19. Avengers 57 Off-White to White Pages (Marvel)

20. Daredevil #1 Off-White Pages (Marvel)

 

 

 

[Nick's Comics]

FANTASY RANKINGS - EVERYTHING BUT DC (For Speculation Only)

 

What if we only tabulated the NON-DC books? That would leave 14 books:

 

Grading Contest Books:

02. The Walking Dead #1 (Image)

04. Famous Funnies #207 (Eastern Color)

05. Unseen #10 Off-White to White Pages (Standard Comics)

06. Fantastic Comics #5 Brittle Pages **cover detached** (Fox Features)

07. Poe Dameron #1 Action Figure Sketch Cover- White Pages (Marvel)

08. Future Comics #2 Off-White Pages (David McKay Publishing)

09. Amazing Spider-Man #104 Off-White to White Pages (Marvel)

11. Krazy Komics #1 Off-White to White Pages (Timely Comics)

12. Chamber of Chills #24 Off-White Pages (Harvey Publications)

16. The Crow #1 - white pages (Caliber)

17. ASM #3 - Off-White Pages (Marvel)

18. ASM #13 - Off-White Pages (Marvel)

19. Avengers 57 Off-White to White Pages (Marvel)

20. Daredevil #1 Off-White Pages (Marvel)

 

 

 

36th place for me!!!

 

Thanks for making this chart!!!

 

You guys are the best!!! This was my first grading contest and I had a blast. Thanks for putting it on and all of the hard work that it took to make it happen.

[wamh0416]

 

 

Yes, the booby prize went to wamh0416. He had the lowest score while submitting grades for all 10 rounds.

 

[Ken Aldred]

 

Yes, the booby prize went to wamh0416. He had the lowest score while submitting grades for all 10 rounds.

 

 

I wanted the accolade so, so badly, but lost out to a better player, who tactically waited until the very last round to relegate me to silver medal position.

 

Congrats, nonetheless, on your achievement !