General discussion thread - keep the other threads clean 29 29

[mica]

He has the advantage of having his name in blue, so I can find his posts quickly.

 

... why didn't it revert back to the old color?

[sborock]

He has the advantage of having his name in blue, so I can find his posts quickly.

 

... why didn't it revert back to the old color?

 

Because I would rather speak my mind and not represent CGC while doing so. I could have kept my "color", but then I would not be able to speak freely.

 

I would never want to tarnish CGC's image in any way, love those people (thumbs u , but having my name different than others means that some people will take what I say as CGC's opinion or that they condone everything I say and that is not what should happen.

 

 

 

 

[General Zod]

He has the advantage of having his name in blue, so I can find his posts quickly.

 

... why didn't it revert back to the old color?

 

Because I would rather speak my mind and not represent CGC while doing so. I could have kept my "color", but then I would not be able to speak freely.

 

I would never want to tarnish CGC's image in any way, love those people (thumbs u , but having my name different than others means that some people will take what I say as CGC's opinion or that they condone everything I say and that is not what should happen.

 

 

 

 

In other words, you are on Double Secret Probation now?

[sborock]

He has the advantage of having his name in blue, so I can find his posts quickly.

 

... why didn't it revert back to the old color?

 

Because I would rather speak my mind and not represent CGC while doing so. I could have kept my "color", but then I would not be able to speak freely.

 

I would never want to tarnish CGC's image in any way, love those people (thumbs u , but having my name different than others means that some people will take what I say as CGC's opinion or that they condone everything I say and that is not what should happen.

 

 

 

 

In other words, you are on Double Secret Probation now?

 

 

Double Secret Secret Probation.........

 

 

 

[Sal]

So, if someone is selling a PGX book without the label - basically just in a PGX holder - is that kosher?

 

Seems like it would be, but just barely...

[jeBailey]

I feel like that would be just like breaking the book out and selling Raw.

[sborock]

So, if someone is selling a PGX book without the label - basically just in a PGX holder - is that kosher?

 

Seems like it would be, but just barely...

 

I am pretty sure that's a "no".

 

But, either way, it is kind of a " you" to CGC, it is their boards.

[General Zod]

That seller is either intentionally ignorant or he's being a doosh despite his newbie status.

[Sal]

So, if someone is selling a PGX book without the label - basically just in a PGX holder - is that kosher?

 

Seems like it would be, but just barely...

 

I am pretty sure that's a "no".

 

But, either way, it is kind of a " you" to CGC, it is their boards.

 

I see your point, and agree with it to a large degree, but at the same time it's no longer slabbed, so what's the difference between it and a book in a top-loader or fortress?

[GACollectibles]

The issues to date have been selling PGX books(not allowed), selling PGX books but not showing the label(not allowed), and recently posted books shown in PGX holder (one seller indicated book was unslabbed but no new pic was posted, other indicated book would sell as-is(slabbed) or raw(cracked) based on buyer's preference).

 

If CGC truly feels that any of the above scenarios are unacceptable, then maybe stipulating "raw or CGC only" requires photo of item in it's current state to clarify any potential questions. Flip side is to drop the "raw or CGC only" guideline, depending on how strongly CGC feels about PGX books listed here. (We know how Steve feels. )

 

On the other hand Sal's post brings up a good question? What constitutes "raw"? I have never tried to crack a slab just enough to remove a label and leave a book in for protection, but is that unreasonable?

[Gone Phishin']

Its my birthday tonight at midnight.. Someone post some GA for me to ponder/buy!

[Gone Phishin']

We cant sell non-comic stuff here, correct? I have a phone to sell, but hate Ebay..

[comicgrinder]

We cant sell non-comic stuff here, correct? I have a phone to sell, but hate Ebay..

[Gone Phishin']

[Pitboss]

We cant sell non-comic stuff here, correct? I have a phone to sell, but hate Ebay..

 

You could call it the "Bat-phone"

[User 01001010]

Originally Posted By: Gone Phishin'

We cant sell non-comic stuff here, correct? I have a phone to sell, but hate Ebay..

 

 

 

what if i sold a movie related comic and a movie poster for the same movie in the same thread but not in the same post?

 

is that ok or no?

 

j

[SPDREYCER]

What about Graded Action Figures?

[trmoore54]

We cant sell non-comic stuff here, correct? I have a phone to sell, but hate Ebay..

 

Throw a modern comic book in with it and you should be cool...

[Gone Phishin']

Rasl #1 NM for $100 with a free Blackberry 8830??

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[inconceivable]

This is a suggestion for the probation forum. Can we put the name of the person who put the offender onto the probation list next to the offender? It would help for others who want to find out what happened by having a name to PM. The probation thread is impossible to search by itself.

 

Thanks.

Dan