Can A f vf have a stain like that!!

[Daredevil]

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2166770747&category=33808

[ubiquiti]

Not with the flaws on the front cover. That makes that a F, maybe F+ in my book.

[Crowzilla]

Well obviously it can, cause there it is listed as a F/VF - and no on eBay ever misgrades.

 

Although I think if I was listing it, I would probably say it was a Vg/Vg-

(but that's just me).

 

[Mushroom]

Fine. Anyway, since when are 70's comics in F/VF regarded as being in high grade?? Have I missed something??

[ubiquiti]

"High-Grade" varies from collector to collector. I think there was a thread about that a few weeks back. I think almost everyone agreed it was above VF, some said only NM and above, but with comic sellers like that - the fact that they put VF in the description makes it in their semi-unethical way of thinking - high grade.

[Ares]

[!@#%^&^] that...

Look at the title

NICK FURY & AGENYS OF SHIELD #1*HIGH GRADE

 

Whats an Agenys?

 

 

 

[ninanina]

Looks like some kinda "bugaboo" stain on the back. Maybe a qualified VF-? If no qualified, then nothing better that F+ at best. That bottom right corner looks hand sculpted shaped like that.

 

Tough call 'cause CGC does not grade back covers too harshly. Kind of amazing what they allow in 9.0's anyway.

 

(Oh no, with that bugaboo stain remark, I think I might be actually encouraging him.)

[Ares]

I wonder why some of the stain didnt bleed onto the cover.

[greggy]

Looks like a rusty bottom staple with the rust stain migrating to the rest of the cover due to the moisture damage!

[ninanina]

Yeah, never noticed the rusty staple. With that, I wouldn't even give this comic a VG. I don't think this comic will sell. Not at that price.

 

Oh yeah, to answer the question of this post, even if the rest of the comic was perfect, I still don't think anyone could still grade it a VF. In a case like that, a qualified grade would probably kick in.

 

[Ares]

Looks like a rusty bottom staple with the rust stain migrating to the rest of the cover due to the moisture damage!

 

Well the cover Scene is set under water.

 

[blowout]

That book is a VG+ at best. By no stretch of the imagination is it high grade.

[Bugaboo-migration]

(Oh no, with that bugaboo stain remark, I think I might be actually encouraging him.)

 

Nah.....it's plain to see that it's definitely a greggy stain.

 

[greggy]