• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

ComicSupply Grading Contest Round 2

Started by ComicSupply,

167 posts in this topic

ComicSupply

ComicSupply

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Again, here is a book that I really thought would grade much higher. I guess I understand now that a tanned book, isn't worth a darn. I guess live and learn huh. I like many of you thought it would be higher.

 

asm64lab.jpg

 

WINNERS BRACKET

 

#1 9.0 Stays in Winners

#3 9.4 Goes to Losers

 

#4 7.5 Stays in Winners

#6 9.2 Goes to Losers

 

#7 9.0 Stays in Winners

#9 NO GRADE Goes to Losers

 

#11 9.0 Goes to Losers

#12 8.5 Stays in Winners

 

#14 9.2 Goes to Losers

#15 7.0 Stays in Winners

 

#16 8.5 Stays in Winners

#18 8.5 Stays in Winners

 

#19 7.5 Stays in Winners

#21 9.0 Goes to Losers

 

#22 9.0 Goes to Losers

#24 8.0 Stays in Winners

 

#26 9.2 Goes to Losers

#28 8.5 Stays in Winners

 

#29 7.0 Goes to Losers

#30 8.5 Stays in Winners

 

#31 9.2 Goes to Losers

#33 8.0 Stays in Winners

 

#34 8.5 Stays in Winners

#35 8.5 Stays in Winners

 

#36 9.0 Stays in Winners

#38 9.0 Stays in Winners

 

#40 7.0 Stays in Winners

#42 9.0 Stays in Winners

 

#43 6.5 Goes to Losers

#44 7.5 Stays in Winners

 

#46 9.0 Goes to Losers

#47 8.5 Stays in Winners

 

#50 8.5 Stays in Winners

#52 9.0 Goes to Losers

 

#53 8.5 Stays in Winners

#56 8.5 Stays in Winners

 

LOSERS BRACKET

 

#5 7.5 Stays in Losers

#8 8.5 Stays in Losers

 

#10 7.0 Stays in Losers

#13 9.2 GOING TO MEGA LOSERS

 

#17 7.0 Stays in Losers

#20 9.2 GOING TO MEGA LOSERS

 

#23 9.0 Stays in Losers

#25 9.2 GOING TO MEGA LOSERS

 

#27 NO GRADE GIVEN GOING TO MEGA LOSERS

#37 8.5 Stays in Losers

 

#39 7.5 Stays in Losers

#41 8.5 Stays in Losers

 

#45 9.2 GOING TO MEGA LOSERS

#48 8.5 Stays in Losers

 

#49 9.0 GOING TO MEGA LOSERS

#51 8.5 Stays in Losers

 

#54 NO GRADE GIVEN GOING TO MEGA LOSERS

#55 8.5 Stays in Losers

 

#32 AUTOMATIC BYE Stays in Losers

 

For Reference:

9.4: 1 Grade Given

9.2: 8 Grades Given

9.0 : 12 Grades Given

8.5: 17 Grades Given

8.0: 2 Grades Given

7.5: 5 Grades Given

7.0: 5 Grades Given

6.5: 1 Grade Given

 

New Round and Face Offs Coming Up in new thread.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
ComicSupply

ComicSupply

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Yeah, it was. I really thought I had something there. I kept it for about 2 years in my to send pile, and finally got the urge to do it. Then blech....

 

Not to mention it was the first book I looked at when I got them back and my heart was just crushed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
the_Greatest

the_Greatest

Posted
Posted

Winners bracket:

 

#1 143ksk

#4 Alberto VO.......1975.

#7 Arty...of course.

#12 casey 1870

#15 deathlok

#16 DNAgent

#18 eaglessbchamps......????

#19 eddly

#24 hobgoblin

#28 joe_collector

#30 mica

#33 norinn radd

#34 october_fire

#35 oldguy

#36 pastandpresentcomics....???

#38 peterjohnson

#40 REDHOOK....dude, take a break!

#42 Sal

#44 Team America 893scratchchin-thumb.gif

#47 the_Greatest.... hi.gif

#50 toro

#52 verygoodplus...........nm/mint

#56 zipper68

 

 

Good Luck!! thumbsup2.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites
rjpb

rjpb

Posted
Posted

I bumped up my grade figuring that CGC went easy on tanning - I guess they do - but sometimes more than others - for me a book that tan wouldn't be higher than a 7.5

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Go to topic listing