ComicSupply Grading Contest Round 3

[kiltman]

#5

That all you got?

[Aces]

AlexH is #5...

[kiltman]

AlexH is #5...

So whats #29 then?

[AlexH]

AlexH is #5...

 

As soon as I saw that I was facing Aces, I knew we were destined to tie and go on to the next round.

[BellaDonna]

Ok, here are the results.

 

7.0 = 3 grades given

7.5 = 5 grades given

8.0 = 13 grades given

8.5 = 14 grades given

9.0 = 11 grades given

9.2 = 2 grades given

9.4 = 1 grades given

9.6 = 2 grades given

 

 

 

 

WINNERS BRACKET

#1 9.2 Stays in Winners

#4 8.0 Goes to Losers

 

#7 9.0 Stays in Winners

#12 8.5 Goes to Losers

 

#15 9.0 Stays in Winners

#16 7.0 Goes to Losers

 

#18 8.5 Stays in Winners

#19 7.5 Goes to Losers

 

#24 8.5 Goes to Losers

#28 9.0 Stays in Winners

 

#30 9.0 Stays in Winners

#33 9.0 Stays in Winners

 

#34 9.0 Stays in Winners

#35 8.0 Goes to Losers

 

#36 8.0 Stays in Winners

#38 8.0 Stays in Winners

 

#40 7.0 Goes to Losers

#42 7.5 Stays in Winners

 

#44 8.0 Stays in Winners

#47 9.6 Goes to Losers

 

#50 8.5 Stays in Winners

#53 8.5 Stays in Winners

 

#56 STAYS IN WINNER BYE

 

LOSERS BRACKET

#3 8.5 Stays in Losers

#5 7.0 Goes to Mega Losers

 

#6 8.5 Stays in Losers

#8 8.0 Goes to Mega Losers

 

#9 9.4 Goes to Mega Losers

#10 8.5 Stays in Losers

 

#11 8.0 Goes to Mega Losers

#14 9.0 Stays in Losers

 

#17 9.0 Stays in Losers

#21 9.0 Stays in Losers

 

#22 8.5 Stays in Losers

#23 8.5 Stays in Losers

 

#26 8.0 Stays in Losers

#31 8.0 Stays in Losers

 

#32 8.5 Goes to Mega Losers

#37 9.0 Stays in Losers

 

#39 7.5 Goes to Mega Losers

#41 9.2 Stays in Losers

 

#43 8.0 Stays in Losers

#46 No Grade Goes to Mega Losers

 

#48 9.6 Stays in Losers

#51 7.5 Stays in Losers

 

#52 8.5 Stays in Losers

#55 8.0 Goes to Mega Losers

 

#29 BYE Stays in Losers

 

MEGA LOSERS BRACKET

 

#13 7.5 Eliminated

#25 8.0 Stays in Mega Losers

 

#27 8.5 Stays in Mega Losers

#45 8.0 Eliminated

 

#49 8.0 Eliminated

#54 8.5 Stays in Mega Losers

 

#20 BYE Stays in Mega Losers

[Sal]

#40 7.0 Goes to Losers

#42 7.5 Stays in Winners

 

oh my God, thank you Red for flubbing it worse than i flubbed it!

 

woo woo!

[october]

 

#34 9.0 Stays in Winners

#35 8.0 Goes to Losers

 

 

Another worthy opponent. I am honored to have defeated you.

[Alberto1975]

#1 9.2 Stays in Winners

#4 8.0 Goes to Losers

 

[mica]

#30 9.0 Stays in Winners

#33 9.0 Stays in Winners

 

This is going to be a long drawn out war.

That kitty kat is tougher than I thought.

 

But the good news is, I nailed it again.

[Aces]

AlexH is #5...

 

As soon as I saw that I was facing Aces, I knew we were destined to tie and go on to the next round.

 

Sorry...

 

Now I'm suppose to be happy about being a loser...?

 

Don't people move "back up" if they win?

 

*goes to find "The Rules" thread*

[Hobgoblin]

CGC Grade = 9.0

 

#24 8.5 Goes to Losers

#28 9.0 Stays in Winners

 

#36 8.0 Stays in Winners

#38 8.0 Stays in Winners

 

I know that this is just how this contest works out, but something just still bothers me about this fact.

[kiltman]

AlexH is #5...

 

As soon as I saw that I was facing Aces, I knew we were destined to tie and go on to the next round.

 

Sorry...

 

Now I'm suppose to be happy about being a loser...?

 

Don't people move "back up" if they win?

 

*goes to find "The Rules" thread*

Nope, it's a fight to stay in that bracket.

[s-man]

9.0?? Really? Im gonna start sending in some books with "light stains" and a nice soft corner...I cant wait for the 9.0's to roll in!!!

[Aces]

AlexH is #5...

 

As soon as I saw that I was facing Aces, I knew we were destined to tie and go on to the next round.

 

Sorry...

 

Now I'm suppose to be happy about being a loser...?

 

Don't people move "back up" if they win?

 

*goes to find "The Rules" thread*

Nope, it's a fight to stay in that bracket.

 

I just re-read them.

[Hobgoblin]

9.0?? Really? Im gonna start sending in some books with "light stains" and a nice soft corner...I cant wait for the 9.0's to roll in!!!

 

me too!

 

As a side note, if this were in the same format as nikos previous contest, I would feel very proud of my performance thus far.

[Arty]

#48 9.6 Stays in Losers

#51 7.5 Stays in Losers

 

Grading Gods smiled to these guys today...

[Alberto1975]

If only we could get CGC to actually participate in these contests and explain why they grade a comic a certain way (not that it will ever happen, but it would be cool and insightful)

 

35 people thought that comic didn't merit a 9.0

11 people thought it was a 9.0

5 people thought it was better than a 9.0

 

I personally think 9.0 is a bit high, but hey

 

I like seeing board members undergrade rather than overgrade, and that's why I like to deal with board members!

[THE_BEYONDER]

1 minute I grade left

 

# 46 THE_BEYONDER

 

BOOM!

 

That was Beyonder shooting himself in the foot.

 

 

[Hobgoblin]

If only we could get CGC to actually participate in these contests and explain why they grade a comic a certain way (not that it will ever happen, but it would be cool and insightful)

 

35 people thought that comic didn't merit a 9.0

11 people thought it was a 9.0

5 people thought it was better than a 9.0

 

I personally think 9.0 is a bit high, but hey

 

I like seeing board members undergrade rather than overgrade, and that's why I like to deal with board members!

 

usually, I notice that a lot more people typically overgrade. These results IMHO are a rare occurance.

[verygoodplus]

Unofficial Standings

 

 

WINNERS

 

#1 143ksk

#7 arty

#15 deathlok

#18 eaglessbchamps

#28 joe_collector

#30 mica

#33 Norinn Radd

#34 october_fire

#36 pastandpresentcomics

#38 PeterJohnson

#42 Sal

#44 FlyingDonut

#50 toro

#53 Warlord

#56 Zipper68

 

 

 

LOSERS

 

#3 Aces

#4 Alberto1975

#6 aman619

#10 bullseye

#12 casey1870

#14 davidking623

#17 drbanner

#19 eddly

#21 Fan4Fan

#22 FFB

#23 gaute

#24 Hobgoblin

#26 inconceivable

#29 kiltman

#31 Nefaria

#35 OldGuy

#37 PedigreeMan

#40 Redhook

#41 rjpb

#43 Slacker

#47 the_Greatest

#48 the_Kingpin

#51 uclapeterg

#52 verygoodplus

 

 

 

MEGA-LOSERS

 

#5 AlexH

#8 bobpfef

#9 Brockley

#11 Burntboy

#20 ericc123

#25 ImageMask

#27 jbud73

#32 nikos61

#39 Postal

#46 THE_BEYONDER

#54 wasonff

#55 xsmanx

 

 

 

ELIMINATED

 

#13 CW

#45 thanos_oftitan

#49 Theagenes