Millie 2 0

[Montezuma]

I have a couple books back from CGC where I was off by at least 1.0, usually I'm within +/- .5

In any case I figured it would be fun to check what others think. First is a Millie 2. Joey did his magic on the slight spine roll before grading

Graders notes below, sorry I don't have a back cover scan,I  will give the CGC grade later

[Gnasher]

3.0

[D84]

2.5-3.0

Edited March 9, 2019 by D84

[Point Five]

Tough one; bright and pretty but a number of flaws. I'll say it squeaks out a 3.5?

 

[FoggyNelson]

3 minutes ago, Point Five said:

Tough one; bright and pretty but a number of flaws. I'll say it squeaks out a 3.5?

 

I will go with 3.5 also 

great book too😞😊😊😊🤔👍🆒

[1950's war comics]

3.5 it is !

[Montezuma]

Well on this one it looks like I was too tough,I was expecting a 1.8, hoping for 2.0 with the press. It got 2.5 so I was happy

[timfinz]

Spoiler

3.5 IMHO!

 

[ThothAmon]

Front cover should get you a 4.0 but guessing what back cover offers I’ll say 3.0. 

[1950's war comics]

1 hour ago, Montezuma said:

Well on this one it looks like I was too tough,I was expecting a 1.8, hoping for 2.0 with the press. It got 2.5 so I was happy

presents better but 2.5 isn't all that bad with all that writing on the cover ...

[FoggyNelson]

I bet it looks real nice in the Cgc holder