ASM #17 needs a good harsh grade... slab worthy???

[Johnny G]

Well... this will be it for today. I don't want to wear out my welcome.

 

I just feel like a kid in a comic book store again! It's been a while since I've had these beauties in my hands

 

Thanks to all who replied

[Foolkiller]

5.5/6.0 bazillion stresses on the spine, nice gloss, nice fine though.

[Johnny G]

That was harsh! I would have been closer to a seven.. guess that's why I need help!!!

 

Thanks for the input...

 

[Foolkiller]

see what other opinions/input there is. I don't like grading books off of scans without seeing the back cover either.

 

Personally, I feel there's a lot of stresses on there plus it looks like some creasing near the spine. The top edge shows quite a bit of wear as well.

 

I think more than a fine would be very generous on that book.

[Johnny G]

I appreciate your help.

 

This is precisely why I joined the site!

[burntboy]

see what other opinions/input there is. I don't like grading books off of scans without seeing the back cover either.

 

Personally, I feel there's a lot of stresses on there plus it looks like some creasing near the spine. The top edge shows quite a bit of wear as well.

 

I think more than a fine would be very generous on that book.

 

i think it shows well, but agree that there are a bundle of spine stresses on this one and the upper edge has it's share of problems. i was thinking 5.5 from the getgo, but being a Marvel it mght pull a 6.0..............

[Black Hawk]

Looks like 6.0

[dc eng]

6.0

[Aces]

6.0

[sterlingcomics]

FN 6.0

[KingOfRulers]

Yup. 6.0.

[casey1870]

At the very least a 6.0....