Point Five's 2nd Annual Grading Contest: ROUND 1 BOOKS! 10 10

[s-man]

Just now, Point Five said:

3. Eerie Adventures #1

The average was best on this one; most of you were in the ballpark. VGish with various flaws.
 

Bullseye #2! 

[AJD]

I missed every book by... point five.

[CHASEnBLUE]

1 minute ago, shiverbones said:

8 points so far.... 

How many points for .5 off? 

[kav]

I'll try to bounce back in future rounds but its gonna be hard with a leg like this

[Comics4All]

Just now, Point Five said:

3. Eerie Adventures #1

The average was best on this one; most of you were in the ballpark. VGish with various flaws.
 

Bullseye!!!!! 

[grendelbo]

2 bulleyes outta 3!

[ADAMANTIUM]

Off by .5

On 2 of them 

And way off on 1

I've not relinquished the victory by crom 

[BrianNichols]

5 minutes ago, Point Five said:

2. Eerie (Avon) #1   

And here's one where I screwed the pooch. Hoping for a 1.5, 1.8 on a good day... but CGC no likey complete split reattached with tape. I feel vindicated at least that a bunch of you agreed with me.   
 

I see it as "numerous major defects" versus "heavy accumulation of major defect"  Oh well . . .learning here

[CHASEnBLUE]

5 minutes ago, Point Five said:

3. Eerie Adventures #1

The average was best on this one; most of you were in the ballpark. VGish with various flaws.
 

Too low again...

Edited July 15, 2021 by CHASEnBLUE

[ADAMANTIUM]

Who got the triple word score, I mean bullseye's?

[shiverbones]

gah! and I had the eerie adventures as a 2.5  oh well

[grendelbo]

Would you mind posting the Graders Notes for these if you have the chance?

☮️

[Point Five]

Round 1 Results thread coming up.

 

[adampasz]

Just now, shiverbones said:

gah! and I had the eerie adventures as a 2.5  oh well

Me too. I thought more would be deducted for the spine splits.

[adampasz]

This round was just the warm up, right?

[Point Five]

2 minutes ago, grendelbo said:

Would you mind posting the Graders Notes for these if you have the chance?

☮️

I can do that. I don't have them for the Eerie Adventures but here's the other two:

Action Comics 48 
light cover tanning
light creasing to cover
light spine stress lines to cover
light stacking bend
light staple tears
tape centerfold

2. Eerie 1
detached cover
light pieces out to cover
light staining to cover
moderate creasing to cover
moderate tears to cover
re-attached with tape spine
split spine

[CHASEnBLUE]

[adampasz]

@Point Five Curious, on the Eerie Advs., how much of the spine is actually split vs. just worn?

 

[Point Five]

2 minutes ago, adampasz said:

@Point Five Curious, on the Eerie Advs., how much of the spine is actually split vs. just worn?

 

This is the one book I didn't submit and I honestly can't tell myself; that's why I went with the pics. I don't think it's horrible? Maybe 20% or so cumulative split if I had to throw out a guess.
 

[Point Five]

Round 1 Results here.