How much does an unverified signature devalue a key issue? 0

[O Doyle Rules]

On 8/16/2022 at 9:15 AM, shadroch said:

But they won't grade the same. CGC will consider the signature a defect. IF the other company determines it is legit, it will enhance the value of the book.

I understood that already - that is why I suggested using CBCS verified signature program earlier in the thread for this comic. I was just talking hypothetically - IF two comics graded the same, the CGC would fetch more money. Is that generally true? CGC more desirable than CBCS? 

[shadroch]

On 8/16/2022 at 7:12 AM, O Doyle Rules said:

I understood that already - that is why I suggested using CBCS verified signature program earlier in the thread for this comic. I was just talking hypothetically - IF two comics graded the same, the CGC would fetch more money. Is that generally true? CGC more desirable than CBCS? 

My limited experiance with CBCS is I can buy them cheaper and sell them for a bit less but my profit margin is similar.  That is over the course of selling a few dozen slabs. If I were selling thousands of slabs, I imagine the gap would be larger. I've had a few people ask for a book and when I showed them a CBCS slab, they weren't interested but in my small sample I don't see much difference myself.  I'm sure there are some crazy examples out there that the seejawcites will use as if they represent the real gap.