Please help me understand CGC grading and consistency. 0

[Mcornwell]

Hello all, 

I'm looking for an explanation on the below.

I have two cards that were originally perfect quad 10's.

I resubmitted them and they came back 9.5/9

That's a big difference. I'm just wondering what happened and where is the consistency?

Espeon V UR

Cert 4036796045 regraded as 4134301001

Dragapult VMAX

Cert 4078900017 regraded as 4134301002

Do you know how this could happen? The grades are so far off that I feel defrauded. I purchased the quad 10 cases on eBay btw but did go through the eBay authentication process.

Edited October 11, 2022 by Mcornwell

[Yeahiwasder4dat]

Did they crack the slabs or you for regrade?

Weirdest change imo is centering grade. That should be static regardless of anything else on the card.

[SnorlaxCollective]

Why did you resubmit perfect 10s....? 🤑😵

[Fiacs0.o]

Would be great to hear from CGC why this happened, especially centering.

Bet you don't hear a word though. Grading companies are all the same at the end of the day man, they're just throwing darts at numbers half the time.

Edited November 10, 2022 by Fiacs0.o