2022 CGC Grading Contest Season 1 Fall Edition (#4) Round 2 9 9

[universal soldier]

Grades in!

 

[ArcherC]

In!

[Old Fashion PB and J]

Sent, IDK why they were not sent already. But they are now

[CGC Mike]

This round is closed.  I will make 3 posts.  The first one will be the reveal of the CGC slabs.  The second one will be the graders notes for the books.  The third one will be a link to round 3.

[CGC Mike]

[CGC Mike]

Exciting Comics #32

Staple detached front cover

Chews left bottom of back cover

Chews left top of back cover

Chews right top of front cover

Staple tears

Moderate creasing to cover

Staining to cover

 

Brave and Bold #28

Light staple tears

wear all corners

wear spine breaks color

multiple crease right top of back cover

multiple crease left bottom of back cover

small piece out right bottom of back cover

 

Captain Marvel #1

Very light stain right top of back cover

Light, multiple crease left top of back cover

Light wear bottom of front cover breaks color

Light crease left center of back cover

 

Lois Lane #113

Moderate wear all corners of cover

Light spine stress lines to cover

Light soiling on cover

 

New Mutants #98

Very light wear right center of front cover breaks color

Very light spine stress lines

Crease right bottom of front cover breaks color

[CGC Mike]

Here's a link to round 3

 

[sledgehammer]

2 bullseyes.

4 points.

NM 98, only 2 grade miss. 

[universal soldier]

1 bullseye, under-graded both the BB and the NM by one grade so not bad. Swing and a miss on the Captain Marvel, didn't see all the other defects other than the stain , will have to give that one another look. I think 7 points for me this round 

[ADAMANTIUM]

1 bullseye, but 8 crazy points  total 

[universal soldier]

Good to know I guess that you can have a small corner crease on a 9.2. I would never give a book like that anything over a 9.0.

[g-man]

Close on the 1st 4….missed the NM 98…that is a generous 9.2 

[CGC Mike]

I haven't recorded everyone's grades yet.  I will do so this evening.  I believe I can get CGC to give me the results and the spread for this round late tomorrow morning.  

[Old Fashion PB and J]

2 bullseye, 2 off by .5, and miss on B&B

[Old Fashion PB and J]

So a 5 for that round

[comicginger1789]

I nailed the Exciting

I whiffed on the Brave and Bold. 3.5 from me. I was harsh on the back. 3 points

I was a grade high on Cap Marvel and Lois Lane. 2 points

And the NM98. I was at 8.5 with that corner crease and spine wear. I own an 8.5 and it looks miles better than this 9.2 (mine has no corner crease and the spine wear isn’t bad) so of all these this is one I disagree with the most. 2 points

7 total

[frozentundraguy]

Much better round for me. Went from 12 points down to 7, and also had the NM98 at 8.5 due to the corner crease. Still no bullseyes though.

Edited November 5, 2022 by frozentundraguy

[ADAMANTIUM]

I missed by the most on captain marvel,  I though it was vf sure, but vfbm maybe, gave it 9.0.

I missed the possible bends

[skypinkblu]

I'm still within reach of my magic number of 17, but I don't think I'm gong to get there;) that would mean just 3 points for   the next two rounds, total..

Edited November 5, 2022 by skypinkblu
If I could add it would help;)

[thehumantorch]

As my hero Maxwell Smart would say