Best Cover????

[MutantKeys]

Amazing Spiderman #50 or X-men #50??

[october]

ASM 50

[arexcrooke]

ASM 50

Yep

[COI]

ASM 50, though 51 is just as good.

[batman_fan]

I have always liked 69 and 75

[COI]

I have always liked 69 and 75

 

Yep, those are choice covers as well.

[blowout]

ASM 50

Yep

 

yep too

[heartened]

I have always liked 69 and 75

 

Yeah, I like the 75 too

[blowout]

I have always liked 69 and 75

 

Yeah, I like the 75 too

 

I bet you do! (insert jealousy graemlin here)

[Guardian Comics]

ASM #50 hands down. I'm an original X-Men guy as well and have never understood the fascination with that cover as well as a lot of the later covers. Neal Adams, wonderful artist, but I would rather see his rendition of Juggernaut then Sauron.

 

Jim

[ashrael]

Definately Spidey 50, but I prefer ASM 33. I don't think that 51 is really that great.

[OldGuy]

As an X-Men fan, and someone who has never been into Spider-Man, I think the ASM 50 cover is the better of the two.

[KingOfRulers]

. I guess I'm the only one to like the X-men #50 cover better. I've never been fond of the Spidey #50 cover.

[Wrightson fan]

. I guess I'm the only one to like the X-men #50 cover better. I've never been fond of the Spidey #50 cover.

 

 

I would have to second you on this one. The Spidey is a true classic, but I will have to go with the Steranko cover. I have always loved the 50 and it is on my short list of books to buy in 9.4 in '06. Something about Polaris and the green/yellow glow of the cover that i've always loved.

 

 

 

Scott

[Sal]

. I guess I'm the only one to like the X-men #50 cover better. I've never been fond of the Spidey #50 cover.

 

 

I would have to second you on this one. The Spidey is a true classic, but I will have to go with the Steranko cover. I have always loved the 50 and it is on my short list of books to buy in 9.4 in '06. Something about Polaris and the green/yellow glow of the cover that i've always loved.

 

 

 

Scott

 

me three.

 

personally, i think it's Steranko's best cover for any title.

 

i wouldn't put the ASM 50 in my top five SA covers.

 

subjective taste in cover appeal rules!

 

[FourthWorld]

I know this file is Big, But it is COOL!!

[FourthWorld]

another time

[jjreason-migration]

X-Men 50 beats ASM 50 - but ASM 69 beats them both. The real question in my mind is this: does SIlver Surfer 4 beat ASM 69?

[blowout]

X-Men 50 beats ASM 50 - but ASM 69 beats them both. The real question in my mind is this: does SIlver Surfer 4 beat ASM 69?

 

The subject matter plays a huge part here, not just the asthetic appeal. There is no doubt that ASM #50 is the more iconic cover. Period.

[mr_highgrade]