Opinions On This DC 404

[nik]

OWW pages, clean back cover (I know, I know most like to see it before coming up with a grade)

 

 

[october]

Pack it up and send it to me for a personal evaluation.

 

Selling?

[nik]

 

Not the DC run, only if I upgrade, I will sell the dupes.

[Timulty]

The Grading Bastiche says.....8.0

[october]

 

Not the DC run, only if I upgrade, I will sell the dupes.

 

 

Looks like a 9.0 to me.

[-cryptkeeper-]

8.5 for me

[Point Five]

8.5/9.0. Very sharp!

[divad]

8.5/9.0. Very sharp!

 

8.75

 

 

[marvelcollector]

8.5...assuming BC is consistent....

[B-Smooth]

8.5 for sure

[Point Five]

8.5/9.0. Very sharp!

 

8.75

 

 

 

OK, maybe it's wussy, but I usually give a two-grade range for books on this forum. It's tough to really fine-tune a grade without having a book in hand, especially when the scans are reduced and a bit on the fuzzy side.

 

Would you settle for "8.5 with full 9.0 potential"?

[lovelyanna-migration]

8.50 - 9.0

[B-Smooth]

Yeah...you guys have to use them balls of yours and start using ONE grade per book!

[Timulty]

!!!!

[lovelyanna-migration]

[lovelyanna-migration]

!!!!

haha, because I have none of those (thank God!) I feel that for me to use two grades is perfectly acceptable haha:) without holding the book how can you pin an exact grade? It may smell like poo or have things wrong with the spine that we cant see

[burntboy]

well i got 'em and i'm still saying 8.5 - 9.0......................

[nearmint]

Here's a 9.0 for comparison...

 

 

[inconceivable]

OWW pages, clean back cover (I know, I know most like to see it before coming up with a grade)

 

9.0 VF/NM Scan is too small. Where is the back cover? Don't me. As I told october, my Lakers are losing to Golden State.

 

Dan