Anyone watching the Eerie No.1 on Ebay tonight

[jeffb]

Just broke the $700 mark today with ~3 hours to go. A 9.6 sold on comiclink for $495

[Bronty]

link?

[jeffb]

link?

 

2,421.48

[RedRaven]

No provenance given. No way to know if it is genuine. I wish the winner the best of luck.

[Crowzilla]

Given that the seller is one of the biggest dealers in Warren magazines in the country I would say the buyer is pretty safe.

 

Also the Comiclink one was for a 2nd printing - which is a nice way to say bootleg. $495 for a bootleg? No thanks.

 

Real Eerie #1s are very tough and well worth the price paid.

[RedRaven]

Given that the seller is one of the biggest dealers in Warren magazines in the country I would say the buyer is pretty safe.

 

I'd say anyone buying an eerie 1 is taking a large gamble , especially with no provenance given. I'm not saying the seller is knowingly selling a counterfeit, I'm saying there is just no way to know.

[jediknight]

Cool mag but those nerdbaits at the end bid it up into nonsensical silliness. How will the winner ever recover? I know if he sells it in 2106.

[the blob]

for $2K it can be sent to CGC and certified. If it's a fake..well, he takes paypal, so they might do something,and with 1300+ feedback, he may not want to get hit with a "counterfeit" in the feedback, but who knows.

[Weird]

for $2K it can be sent to CGC and certified. If it's a fake..well, he takes paypal, so they might do something,and with 1300+ feedback, he may not want to get hit with a "counterfeit" in the feedback, but who knows.

 

CGC does not certify Eerie #1.

[the blob]

so what was the 9.6 on clink? they just certify everything as a potential counterfeit?

[Weird]

so what was the 9.6 on clink? they just certify everything as a potential counterfeit?

 

Link? Was it CGC graded?

[RedRaven]

If it was CGC graded it was probably the Avon #1 unless CGC has changed their policy regarding 'xeroxed' comics.

[Weird]

If it was CGC graded it was probably the Avon #1 unless CGC has changed their policy regarding 'xeroxed' comics.

 

I thought we were discussing Warren's EERIE?

[RedRaven]

If it was CGC graded it was probably the Avon #1 unless CGC has changed their policy regarding 'xeroxed' comics.

 

I thought we were discussing Warren's EERIE?

 

We are/were. Was suggesting that the CGC graded Eerie 1 mentioned on clink might have been the Avon horror comic rather than the Warren "ashcan".

[rabidwolf]

what about this?

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/EERIE-1-1947-CGC-VF-...1QQcmdZViewItem

[RedRaven]

what about this?

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/EERIE-1-1947-CGC-VF-...1QQcmdZViewItem

 

That's the Avon comic.

[precodekeith]

what about this?

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/EERIE-1-1947-CGC-VF-...1QQcmdZViewItem

 

That's the Avon comic.

 

I dunno, last guide I bought (# 34) had the Avon EERIE at $3,700 in 9.0. I think this guy is shooting for the stars at $5,500 , but there probably is some fool who will pay up.

[Weird]

what about this?

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/EERIE-1-1947-CGC-VF-...1QQcmdZViewItem

 

That's the Avon comic.

 

I dunno, last guide I bought (# 34) had the Avon EERIE at $3,700 in 9.0. I think this guy is shooting for the stars at $5,500 , but there probably is some fool who will pay up.

 

Heritage has a raw GD up in this week's auctions. It's at $220 now. Doesn't LW Gallery have something to do with Heritage (or not)? Not a big GA collector, but that is a book I would def. like to own.

[october]

This thread went all over the place. Can anyone give difinitive answers to these questions, just to clarify things?

 

1. Does CGC certify (or have they certified) ANY Warren Eerie 1s?

 

2. Is there any way to tell real Eerie 1s from fake Eerie 1s?

 

3. If not, where do those lines in Overstreet come from?

[precodekeith]

This thread went all over the place.

 

Yes, it did.