If you had to pick just one? First come, First Serve. Fantasy comic league?

[MCMiles]

Rules.

One of every comic in 9.0 to choose from.

You can only pick one.

Would never be able to sell (to offset monetary influence)

 

I will go first.

I pick Detective #27

 

We'll have to keep track of previously picked books ourselves

[CW]

Detective #31, (sorry Norrin)!

[CW]

Oh maybe I should ask, What are we doing?

[AlexH]

Action #1

[drice6900]

Captain America #1 (Golden Age).

[goldust40]

Marvel Comics 1 (October edition).

[Darrell F]

Batman #1

[arexcrooke]

Either All-Winners 1 or More Fun 52

[drice6900]

Hey, just realized I topped 4000 posts

[FlamingCarrot]

Visions #1!

[Timulty]

Double Action #2. Though there are issues of Whiz or Pre-Hero Tecs, Action or Adventures that would be Great as Well.

[Bronty]

Fantastic Four 1

 

--if I understand the rules correctly. I.e. you don't have to pony up the cash, you can never sell it, it's the only book in your collection.

[FlyingDonut]

Rules.

One of every comic in 9.0 to choose from.

You can only pick one.

Would never be able to sell (to offset monetary influence)

 

I will go first.

I pick Detective #27

 

We'll have to keep track of previously picked books ourselves

 

um, what's the criteria here? Amazing Fantasy 15

[kidcolt]

Pep # first Archie

[october]

Detective 1

[BachelorOfComix]

I don't know what the heck is going on but I'll say All Star Comics 3.

[Comicdey]

I'll take the Marvel Comics #1 November edition. (october's taken)

[valiantman]

Funnies On Parade (1933)

[Zonker]

Either All-Winners 1 or More Fun 52

 

Assuming 52 is taken, I'll go with 53.

[UnrulyAppendage]

Superman 1 GA