Which one would you choose?

[october]

COPY A

 

 

 

 

-or-

 

 

COPY B

 

 

[Sal]

A

 

that LRBC on B has issues

[thedarkknight]

A

[Psiknight]

A, for sure.

[Timulty]

The Grading Bastiche says.....A. And if you are selling B, I would be interested.

[kenglo]

A even though the front cover on B is nicer--which is probably obvious to everyone

[143ksk]

A

[Aces]

A

That big freaky yellow line mark across B makes it a no-brainer.

[Anfield Fox]

Neither

[marvelcollector]

A, despite the crescent crease on the TE of BC....

[october]

I am going to buck the trend and keep copy B. A is better technically, but B has deeper blacks and better front cover eye appeal.

 

 

 

Maybe I will keep both.

[drbanner]

I am going to buck the trend and keep copy B. A is better technically, but B has deeper blacks and better front cover eye appeal.

 

Maybe I will keep both.

 

I'm with you there...copy A might garner the better technical grade, but B has a sharper front cover. I know I have a lot of "NM from the front/VF from the back" books in my collection!

[joeypost]

Overall "A".

[inconceivable]

How much cheaper is 'B'? That would be my only reason for going that route.

 

Dan

[Point Five]

I am going to buck the trend and keep copy B. A is better technically, but B has deeper blacks and better front cover eye appeal.

 

I wondered which way you were leaning. I had a slight lean towards A, but I was suspecting those horizontal printing marks on the FC might be more distracting in hand than in the scan. This seems like a comparison easier done with the real books in front of you. And both are nice!

[Earthbornpig]

Guess I am on the A wagon too, but the cover on B has more eye appeal to me. By the way, I have a thick black marker you could borrow to "fix up" that back cover....

[october]

How much cheaper is 'B'? That would be my only reason for going that route.

 

Dan

 

Well, I own them both so I guess neither is cheaper. A was more, and I think I could sell that one a bit easier.

[october]

but I was suspecting those horizontal printing marks on the FC might be more distracting in hand than in the scan.

 

You are a sharp one. They are.

[Sal]

How much cheaper is 'B'? That would be my only reason for going that route.

 

Dan

 

Well, I own them both so I guess neither is cheaper. A was more, and I think I could sell that one a bit easier.

i'll give you six dollars American for it. and a copy of Aquaman 48 in 6.5. i haven't taken the Aquaman out of the bag yet, but it looks pretty solid as far as i can tell

[october]

How much cheaper is 'B'? That would be my only reason for going that route.

 

Dan

 

Well, I own them both so I guess neither is cheaper. A was more, and I think I could sell that one a bit easier.

i'll give you six dollars American for it. and a copy of Aquaman 48 in 6.5. i haven't taken the Aquaman out of the bag yet, but it looks pretty solid as far as i can tell

 

You drive a hard bargain. Throw in some used polybags and a copy of Eternal Warrior 3 and you have a deal.