PGM Incredible Hulk #3

[divad]

 

 

[comic_lot]

5.0/5.5, due mainly to stain on back cover. Is that rust migration on lower staple, and is there a spine tear/split at all? Sharp looking cover overall.

[Carnage]

Front cover is pretty good, but back cover puts it down into the 5.0 range, maybe higher.

[Point Five]

This one is tough...many positives, but the staining is a significant negative. Reminds me a bit of the Avengers #7 I put up...do big flaws not hurt the grade as much if they're mostly on the back? Nice as the front looks, I'd lean towards 4.0/4.5 just b/c of the size of the stain...can't quite see 5.5 range. Still, a beauty!

[Aces]

Oh man.

Without the stain it's a near Fine 5.5.

I'd say 4.0

[october]

That's another new one? Nice!

 

Does the staining go through the whole book? Is it on the front cover?

[Aces]

That's another new one? Nice!

 

He bought 1 - 6.

[marvelcollector]

5.0, mostly due to strange soiling below staple on spine...almost looks like smoke residue...otherwise had a shot at a FN...

[october]

That's another new one? Nice!

 

He bought 1 - 6.

 

Yeah, I know. He just listed it as a lower grade in a PM to me. I was surprised when I saw how nice this one is.

[joeypost]

4.5/5.0

[Psiknight]

One of the nicest 4.0s I've seen.

[Pirate]

4.0 due to the staining but i can't grade so i'm sure it's a 6.0

[Psiknight]

4.0 due to the staining but i can't grade so i'm sure it's a 6.0

 

To be fair, that Hulk 1 isn't close to a 2.0. You're welcome to your opinion on a book, of course, but it's not worth getting all bent out of shape about it if someone else disagrees...

[jimjum12]

Looks 4.5/5.0 to me also.That's one of my favorite comics of all time.Owning the whole run must be SO cool.The best I could ever do was 2-6 and that was a million years ago.Congratulations.GOD BLESS...

 

-jimbo(a friend of jesus)

[divad]

Thanks jimbo . .

[Pirate]

4.0 due to the staining but i can't grade so i'm sure it's a 6.0

 

To be fair, that Hulk 1 isn't close to a 2.0. You're welcome to your opinion on a book, of course, but it's not worth getting all bent out of shape about it if someone else disagrees...

 

Who's bent out of shape

[Holku]

At least 5.0 from me...but I could be wrong. My first thought was 5.5 easy, maybe higher but that back cover is a killer by at least a point.