What Do you Think This Graded?

[nik]

Okay true believers, whats your guess on the grade this book received. And yes, those are small foxing/stains on the upper edge of the back cover

 

 

 

[october]

Are they foxing spots or are they stains? Big difference. CGC goes light on foxing, but REALLY hammers the hell out of a book for stains.

[nik]

Looking at it closer, I would say more like foxing spots.

[october]

8.0

[divad]

7.0 Those yellow lines will kill the grade every time . . .

[nik]

7.0 Those yellow lines will kill the grade every time . . .

 

Its my trademark

[Point Five]

I was thinking 7.0 also...too slow! I'll guess 7.5...

[october]

I wish I still had a scan of an issue of Unexpected Greggy posted one time. That thing was foxed to hell and still got an 8.0. I mean the entire back spine had it. I don't think they would knock an otherwise VF book down much for it. I probably should have gone with 7.5 though.

[Dad&Son-migration]

8.5

[Point Five]

I remember that one too, yeeouch! Never understood the whole logic behind giving foxing a pass.

[Timulty]

The Grading Bastiche says.....7.0 Foxing gets no passes from THE GRADING BASTICHE!!!

[backtomarvel]

7.0

[nik]

You grading bastiche you

[osborn_fr]

9.2 qualified

[nik]

Eggsplain qualified

[divad]

Splain me, Luthy . . .

[nik]

[Aces]

9.2 qualified

[Aces]

My grade:

9.0

 

I'm just taking a wild guess.

This either got a soft high grade, ignoring the foxing, or they killed it and went 6.0.

[nik]

My grade:

9.0

 

I'm just taking a wild guess.

This either got a soft high grade, ignoring the foxing, or they killed it and went 6.0.

 

 

 

We have a winner