• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Which one would you choose ????
2 2

5,844 posts in this topic

Dave is the King . He is the top comic, art and toy colletor of Batman and Superman as well as M.H keys. NOBODY comes close. NOBODY. Its like he is Secretariat in the belmont and im 31 lengths behind him. This is not an exaggeration.

 

Eric's Wacky Pack collection is worth Millions and Millions of dollars. Keep in mind he is on an endless budget, because his pa is worth $2.5 Billion dollars.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

WHy is it better than the DEntist? Eric has a few top copies, a killer Tec run, and a smattering of other keys. At least from what I see on the website. Dentists has tons of books, and has Aces to Eric's kings on most of the keys. including of course the Top Two.

 

What am I missing here?

 

We are getting off topic so I won't elaborate to much. The dentist doesn't have

 

Whiz 1 @ CGC 8.5

Tec 31 @ CGC 8.0

All-Star 8 @ CGC 9.0

Amazing Fantasy 15 @ CGC 9.6

More Fun 52 @ CGC 7.5

Sensation @ CGC 9.0

2 Copies of All America 16 @ CGC 5.5

TOS 30 @ CGC 9.4

 

 

+ The best run of Detective Comics in the world. Mostly Nova Scotia

 

First let me state that I di not know exactly what Dentist has..

BUT - - -

he does have the Church Actions from 1-20

Allentown Tec 27 plus many Church copies and other comparable copies for which he let the Church copies go for.

I thinbk he also has HG runs of Batman all the GA titles too.

plus each of the copies you mention except the AF15

 

um, TOS 30 ???? in THIS company? ha ha.

 

in general, my understanding is that Detist has it all, and in grade. Eric has a very cool HG collection of key books....plus the best existing TOS 30!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

WHy is it better than the DEntist? Eric has a few top copies, a killer Tec run, and a smattering of other keys. At least from what I see on the website. Dentists has tons of books, and has Aces to Eric's kings on most of the keys. including of course the Top Two.

 

What am I missing here?

 

We are getting off topic so I won't elaborate to much. The dentist doesn't have

 

Whiz 1 @ CGC 8.5

Tec 31 @ CGC 8.0

All-Star 8 @ CGC 9.0

Amazing Fantasy 15 @ CGC 9.6

More Fun 52 @ CGC 7.5

Sensation @ CGC 9.0

2 Copies of All America 16 @ CGC 5.5

TOS 30 @ CGC 9.4

 

 

+ The best run of Detective Comics in the world. Mostly Nova Scotia

 

First let me state that I di not know exactly what Dentist has..

BUT - - -

he does have the Church Actions from 1-20

Allentown Tec 27 plus many Church copies and other comparable copies for which he let the Church copies go for.

I thinbk he also has HG runs of Batman all the GA titles too.

plus each of the copies you mention except the AF15

 

um, TOS 30 ???? in THIS company? ha ha.

 

in general, my understanding is that Detist has it all, and in grade. Eric has a very cool HG collection of key books....plus the best existing TOS 30!

 

I meant TOS #39 @ CGC 9.4. Sorry I've had one to many beers.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dave is the King . He is the top comic, art and toy colletor of Batman and Superman as well as M.H keys. NOBODY comes close. NOBODY. Its like he is Secretariat in the belmont and im 31 lengths behind him. This is not an exaggeration.

 

Eric's Wacky Pack collection is worth Millions and Millions of dollars. Keep in mind he is on an endless budget, because his pa is worth $2.5 Billion dollars.

 

worth it to whom?

 

I think Eric could have a lot more comics, IF they were for sale. Or maybe he doesnt because he is very selective about what he wants, and doesnt want everything. I dunno. Nice guy though. Maybe when the baby grows up a bit he will spend more time and ($$$) on comics again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote;//We are getting off topic so I won't elaborate to much. The dentist doesn't have

 

Whiz 1 @ CGC 8.5

Tec 31 @ CGC 8.0

All-Star 8 @ CGC 9.0

Amazing Fantasy 15 @ CGC 9.6

More Fun 52 @ CGC 7.5

Sensation @ CGC 9.0

2 Copies of All America 16 @ CGC 5.5

TOS 30 @ CGC 9.4

 

Carolina, not to knock eric but these are daves second hand copies buy comparison. Try on a 9.4 Action 1 for size. A 9.6 Detective 27..he sold a 9.4 whiz 1 to Geppi years ago.His More fun 52 is 9.2.....are you beginnin to get the picture who the king is...I mean this respectfully...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote;//We are getting off topic so I won't elaborate to much. The dentist doesn't have

 

Whiz 1 @ CGC 8.5

Tec 31 @ CGC 8.0

All-Star 8 @ CGC 9.0

Amazing Fantasy 15 @ CGC 9.6

More Fun 52 @ CGC 7.5

Sensation @ CGC 9.0

2 Copies of All America 16 @ CGC 5.5

TOS 39 @ CGC 9.4

 

Carolina, not to knock eric but these are daves second hand copies buy comparison. Try on a 9.4 Action 1 for size. A 9.6 Detective 27..he sold a 9.4 whiz 1 to Geppi years ago.His More fun 52 is 9.2.....are you beginnin to get the picture who the king is...I mean this respectfully...

 

OK fine. But I am just fascinated with Eric's collection because it is online. :D

 

Again I am getting way way :signofftopic:

Edited by CarolinaComix
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You have a point.Its on line nd it is great no dought. I just wanted you to know because I knew the guys were gonna come at you when you thought those copies were better thans daves.

 

Peter by the way I just bought a Authentic NM 1966 XL Batman French Movie Poster. (thumbs u (thumbs u

 

I saw it your room and I became obsessed w/ it.

 

Again :signofftopic:

Edited by CarolinaComix
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Which one would you choose?

 

image_6_1_full.jpg

 

image_485_1_full.jpg

 

Man, this is a tuff one for me. I absolutely love Spiderman, always have. Next to Cap, he is hands down my favorite. Speaking from an investment place if that AMF is indeed the best copy, and I am guessing there are more than one laying around in that condition. I guess, 150K, 200K, or even 500K is just to much for a book that is not rare. Ahhh, but the Action...very rare, less than 100 known copies, you never see a full row of them in any grade( Metro's wall of AmF at Chicago)...Long term I think one or two more 9.6/9.8 amf's will surface.....So after thinking it through....

Action 1 all FUdging day long!!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

just give me one dam good Superman movie for a change and we wouldnt be debating this.

 

The Holy Grail of comicbooks is Action comics # 1.

 

..............................and that book that I can never rremember the name of that Showcase likes s0 much. Mahria the old duck ??? Oh I just dont remember.But its really important.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
2 2